DRS: In defence of an unpopular F1 overtaking aid

The 2021 Formula 1 season will mark the 10th anniversary of the widely-criticised DRS overtaking aid, but STEFAN MACKLEY argues its greatest problem is down to the application by circuits rather than the device itself

DRS: In defence of an unpopular F1 overtaking aid

"Artificial", "gimmick", and "a band-aid" are just some of the words which have been used to describe the Drag Reduction System by its many critics since it was first introduced at the beginning of the 2011 Formula 1 season.

The system - which when activated opens the top element of a car's rear wing, thereby cutting drag - was seen as a quick, affordable and efficient fix to improve overtaking, something severely lacking in the previous refuelling era that generally meant any 'overtaking' was done through pitstops instead of wheel-to-wheel combat.

The need for such a device was perhaps best illustrated at the last race without it - the 2010 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix - where Ferrari's Fernando Alonso spent lap after lap stuck behind Vitaly Petrov, unable to get within striking distance of the Renault to make a pass around the Yas Marina Circuit. That ultimately cost the Spaniard his third F1 drivers' title to Sebastian Vettel.

Since then - barring wet weather - the device has been used at every GP over the last decade and a general apathy towards it by drivers, teams and fans has steadily festered.

But should this be the case? If it's so widely loathed, then why will it be used for the 10th consecutive year once the 2021 F1 season hopefully gets underway in Bahrain next month?

"It will help overtaking," said designer Adrian Newey - one of F1's brightest minds - at the Autosport International show ahead of the 2011 season.

PLUS: How sweeping changes might improve racing in 2011

"It reduces the drag of the car in the straight so it gives extra speed. The key is juggling it and adjusting it so that it makes overtaking possible, but not too easy."

This last point is key. Often the length of the activation zones has meant overtakes are sometimes too easy, leaving armchair critics feeling vindicated. But that's a problem with how each circuit has implemented the system, not a fundamental issue with DRS itself.

It still remains difficult to judge the zones correctly even with a decade's worth of data as a number of variables ultimately determine just how effective it will be, including car power output, downforce levels and wind speed.

Trial and error was the order of the day for much of its inaugural season in 2011, with some circuits implementing two activation zones - a move praised by drivers at the time - and the length of those zones differing to find the perfect middle ground.

"You have to bear in mind what this [DRS] is trying to achieve. It's about giving the car behind that slight advantage to make a move possible that wouldn't have been possible before" James Allison in 2011

Its use that year facilitated one of F1's most memorable comebacks, as Jenson Button activated the system on a drying track during the Canadian GP to pass Michael Schumacher's Mercedes in the closing stages before scampering after Vettel and pressuring him into a mistake that handed him a famous win. Without the device it's unlikely Button would have found a way past Schumacher, and certainly not with enough time to harass Vettel into the error.

PLUS: Jenson Button's 10 greatest F1 races

When the system is implemented correctly it can produce great racing. For example, at the 2017 Spanish GP it allowed, first, Vettel to take the lead from Valtteri Bottas and then Lewis Hamilton the opportunity to make a pass on the Ferrari driver.

The Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya is notoriously difficult to overtake on and while the DRS did offer the opportunity to make overtakes into Turn 1, neither of the above mentioned passes were forgone conclusions.

As then-Renault technical director James Allison said in 2011: "You have to bear in mind what this [DRS] is trying to achieve. It's about giving the car behind that slight advantage to make a move possible that wouldn't have been possible before."

For those who cry that you don't need overtaking for a great and enthralling race - think Gilles Villeneuve holding off a train of faster cars in the 1981 Spanish GP - they have a point, but that's not to say that those instances don't happen even with DRS.

The perfect illustration of this was Bottas' first F1 win at the 2017 Russian GP, where he held a charging Vettel at bay in the closing stages. Critics need only look at the aforementioned Yas Marina Circuit where overtaking is at a premium, even with two DRS zones, to see that the system doesn't necessarily mean overtaking is a certainty.

Over time DRS has been altered, with its unlimited use in practice and qualifying being limited to the race activation zones while the size of the flap has been increased.

The system has also filtered into other avenues of motorsport such FIA Formula 2, FIA Formula 3 and the DTM - which implemented a three-second operating window instead of the conventional one second used in F1 and its support categories in 2019.

But despite its widespread use throughout motorsport, DRS still comes under fire. Speaking about the new F1 technical regulations for 2022, McLaren team principal Andreas Seidl shared his desire that F1 can soon exist without it.

"I still have this dream that with the new regulations from '22 onwards and with the budget cap, that hopefully we get to a position one day again where we could not have any artificial overtaking devices.

"[We could have] simply a great show with a competitive field and with cars that can race each other very closely."

No one would begrudge a more closely fought battle between drivers, but until the powers that be make the necessary technical changes to the cars there remains very few alternatives to improve racing and the spectacle.

Ten years after it was first introduced the DRS system may not be universally loved but, with cars still producing too much air turbulence to follow closely and circuits not catering to the needs of faster and wider machines, it's certainly offered the chance for more overtaking and more entertaining races - regardless of what the critics say.

shares
comments
Why F1's first success handicap could be revolutionary
Previous article

Why F1's first success handicap could be revolutionary

Next article

Haas willing to call on Grosjean or Magnussen as F1 reserve

Haas willing to call on Grosjean or Magnussen as F1 reserve
Why few could blame Leclerc for following the example of Hamilton’s exit bombshell Plus

Why few could blame Leclerc for following the example of Hamilton’s exit bombshell

OPINION: Ferrari's numerous strategy blunders, as well as some of his own mistakes, have cost Charles Leclerc dearly in the 2022 Formula 1 title battle in the first half of the season. Though he is locked into a deal with Ferrari, few could blame Leclerc if he ultimately wanted to look elsewhere - just as Lewis Hamilton did with McLaren 10 years prior

Formula 1
Aug 9, 2022
The other McLaren exile hoping to follow Perez's path to a top F1 seat Plus

The other McLaren exile hoping to follow Perez's path to a top F1 seat

After being ditched by McLaren earlier in his F1 career Sergio Perez fought his way back into a seat with a leading team. BEN EDWARDS thinks the same could be happening to another member of the current grid

Formula 1
Aug 8, 2022
How studying Schumacher helped make Coulthard a McLaren F1 mainstay Plus

How studying Schumacher helped make Coulthard a McLaren F1 mainstay

Winner of 13 grands prix including Monaco and survivor of a life-changing plane crash, David Coulthard could be forgiven for having eased into a quiet retirement – but, as MARK GALLAGHER explains, in fact he’s busier than ever, running an award-winning media company and championing diversity in motor racing. Not bad for someone who, by his own admission, wasn’t quite the fastest driver of his generation…

Formula 1
Aug 7, 2022
Could F1 move to a future beyond carbonfibre? Plus

Could F1 move to a future beyond carbonfibre?

Formula 1 has ambitious goals for improving its carbon footprint, but could this include banishing its favoured composite material? PAT SYMONDS considers the alternatives to carbonfibre and what use, if any, those materials have in a Formula 1 setting

Formula 1
Aug 6, 2022
How Russell has proven he deserves to be Hamilton's Mercedes heir Plus

How Russell has proven he deserves to be Hamilton's Mercedes heir

He’s fast, he’s smart, and he’s already shown he’s not going to let Max Verstappen intimidate him. George Russell won’t say it, but LUKE SMITH says he’s ready to take the lead at Mercedes when Lewis Hamilton moves on to a quieter life. And – whisper it – Mercedes and Lewis are starting to think so too

Formula 1
Aug 5, 2022
The traits that fuelled Alonso's unexpected Aston Martin move Plus

The traits that fuelled Alonso's unexpected Aston Martin move

Fernando Alonso’s bombshell switch to Aston Martin sent shockwaves through Formula 1, not least at Alpine that finds itself tangled in a contract standoff with Oscar Piastri. Not shy of a bold career move and with a CV punctuated by them, there were numerous hints that trouble was brewing

Formula 1
Aug 4, 2022
The elements Ferrari must resolve to first save face, then win championships Plus

The elements Ferrari must resolve to first save face, then win championships

OPINION: Ferrari's Formula 1 title hopes look all but over after another strategic blunder in last week's Hungarian Grand Prix denied Charles Leclerc the chance to fight for victory, while handing it to chief rival Max Verstappen. The Scuderia now faces intense scrutiny over what it must now do to finally become a genuine factor in championship battles

Formula 1
Aug 3, 2022
The clues about Hamilton’s F1 retirement plans revealed after Vettel’s decision Plus

The clues about Hamilton’s F1 retirement plans revealed after Vettel’s decision

OPINION: Sebastian Vettel is set to leave Formula 1 at the end of 2022 and will, rather shockingly, be replaced by Fernando Alonso at Aston Martin. But what about the final chapter of the other driver that defined the post-Michael Schumacher era? In Hungary, Lewis Hamilton spoke about his future in the context of Vettel’s upcoming departure, which offered clues on how long it will last

Formula 1
Aug 2, 2022