Who has the best F1 power unit: Red Bull or Mercedes? Russell shares interesting theory
Max Verstappen believes Mercedes still has the upper hand at energy-poor circuits, but according to George Russell, multiple factors come into play and Mercedes has made compromises in certain areas
Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing, George Russell, Mercedes
The Las Vegas Grand Prix promises to be an interesting challenge for Formula 1 teams in several respects, arguably even more so than in previous years. With the 2026 cars producing less downforce and relying on active aerodynamics, getting temperature into the Pirelli tyres – and, given the long straights, keeping it there – promises to be even more difficult than before.
According to newly crowned world champion Kimi Antonelli, this factor will determine who gets to lift the Las Vegas GP winners' trophy on Saturday night, although another aspect should not be underestimated either: energy management.
During a weekend in which much of the discussion has centred on the return of V8 engines, the reality remains that the 2026 power units have significant limitations, many of which will be exposed again in Las Vegas.
Verstappen described the simulator work as “painful”, a sentiment echoed by other drivers. Clipping is once again expected to play a major role on the long straight, with Antonelli also warning about the return of “yo-yo racing”.
Although that is hardly good news in itself, it does raise an interesting question: who currently has the best power unit at these energy-poor circuits?
At the beginning of this year, the answer was clearly Mercedes, while efficiency on the electrical side of the power unit was still a weakness for Red Bull. Although the newcomer from Milton Keynes has not received an ADUO token and has therefore been unable to make hardware changes, it has made significant progress in terms of efficiency and learning how to optimise its power unit for each circuit.
Nevertheless, Verstappen still points to Mercedes as the benchmark at an energy-poor track like Las Vegas.
Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing
Photo by: Sam Bagnall / Sutton Images via Getty Images
“In Baku, we were probably not the strongest in that regard. I hope that it will be a little bit better here, but I think Mercedes is normally the strongest on that side, with maximising that.”
When Autoport subsequently put those comments to Russell, the Mercedes driver offered a nuanced reply. According to him, it is not so easy to distinguish between the internal combustion engine and the electrical components, and the picture from the beginning of this year is not necessarily valid.
“I do think we've probably got the most efficient electrical management, but I think it's unfair sometimes to separate the two things,” Russell said. “You've got to develop a car and a power unit and a battery deployment setup that all contribute to one another.”
And it is precisely in this respect that different manufacturers and teams make different compromises, according to Russell.
“You can compromise the ICE to give you more, and vice versa. And you can compromise your aero package to give you more power. We could achieve more power from the engine, but we would have to take a sacrifice with the aerodynamics.”
When Russell takes all those factors into account, however, his conclusion is clear: “On the whole, I think Red Bull, on the power unit side, are the team to beat right now. So I just look at that as over the course of a lap and not distinguishing between ICE and battery.”
George Russell, Mercedes
Photo by: Simon Galloway / LAT Images via Getty Images
An interesting point is that, according to Russell, the picture from the beginning of this year is no longer valid for two reasons. Firstly, the competition – particularly Red Bull – has made progress in extracting performance from its power unit, but secondly, Russell says the drag levels of the W17 have changed, particularly following the upgrade in Malaysia.
“I think earlier this year, we had an exceptionally efficient car. With our previous package, we were considerably faster than the other Mercedes power unit cars on the straights,” he said.
“Since we brought the new package, we've added drag to the car. And I think that has kind of scuppered people's views a bit on what's power and what's drag. As I said, you can't just draw a line in the sand and say, it's battery, it's ICE, it's chassis.”
The additional drag mentioned by Russell could potentially be a handicap in Vegas, but it is precisely in this area that his team-mate Antonelli also sees a positive for Mercedes: “I think Red Bull is going to be very strong this weekend. However, I think we're the only one who has a set of wings that is slightly less downforce-wise, so a bit less drag. Let's see if we're going to use it here, but definitely it's going to be very interesting.”
At Monza – another energy-poor circuit – Antonelli produced a particularly memorable recovery drive, his most emotional F1 win to date, but he expects the opposition in Vegas to be stronger than it was at his home race.
“I think our power unit has been very strong on the electrical side, obviously also on the combustion, but the electrical side has been very strong. I think we're probably the most efficient ones in terms of electrical power and efficiency,” Antonelli said.
Andrea Kimi Antonelli, Mercedes
Photo by: Mark Sutton / Formula 1 via Getty Images
“However, Red Bull, they have a very strong power unit as well, and their car is very efficient on the straight, especially with the Macarena wing they have.
“I think our main competitor will be Red Bull this weekend, probably McLaren as well. And let’s see how Ferrari will do here. This track is an outlier, so it’s definitely going to be interesting.”
All the problems with energy management and the 2026 power units are painful to watch, but in a sense, Vegas does provide an interesting benchmark for determining who leads the way at energy-poor circuits – with one crucial caveat, as Antonelli rightly points out: tyre temperature could overshadow everything in Sin City.
Share Or Save This Story
Subscribe and access Autosport.com with your ad-blocker.
From Formula 1 to MotoGP we report straight from the paddock because we love our sport, just like you. In order to keep delivering our expert journalism, our website uses advertising. Still, we want to give you the opportunity to enjoy an ad-free and tracker-free website and to continue using your adblocker.
Top Comments