BAR Want 'Modest Fine' if Found Guilty

BAR's legal team believe that a 'modest fine' would be more than sufficient punishment for the outfit if the FIA's Court of Appeal disagrees with their view that fuel can be used as ballast

BAR Want 'Modest Fine' if Found Guilty

After strongly refuting the FIA's claims that the team deliberately cheated, and in doing so should be thrown out of the 2005 Formula One World Championship, BAR's barrister David Pannick insists the matter comes down to a simple interpretation of F1's rules.

BAR claim that they can use fuel as ballast because there is nothing in the regulations that strictly rules the action out, while the FIA insist that cars cannot use fuel as ballast after an edict laid down at a Technical Working Group hearing in 1994.

If the four appeal court judges rule that Jenson Button's BAR was illegally underweight at the San Marino Grand Prix, he believes that any punishment beyond financial would be unfair.

Summing up his case at the hearing, Pannick urged the judges to reject outright any claims of deliberate cheating and consider carefully that the team believed there was nothing in the F1 regulations that prevents teams from using fuel as ballast.

"There is no evidence that can begin to sustain the grave allegation of their personal integrity," he said. "There is no record that BAR-Honda have acted in a way deceptively or fraudulently in a previous occasion."

He added: "In our submission we ask you to reject any case of fraud, bad faith or deception as not having been proven by the FIA. We say you should also find in our favour of the proper interpretation of the rules.

"If you were to be against us, my submission would be that a fine would be to suffice because we have produced data that without this extra fuel then the car could not have got around the track. In those circumstances a modest fine would be sufficient."

The FIA have insisted, however, that BAR deliberately cheated with the way they used the secondary fuel tank and have called on the Appeal Court to throw the team out of the World Championship and fine it a minimum of one million Euros. 

shares
comments
FIA: BAR Guilty of Fraudulent Conduct
Previous article

FIA: BAR Guilty of Fraudulent Conduct

Next article

Australia to Follow Commonwealth Games

Australia to Follow Commonwealth Games
The time-honoured manufacturer model that can't apply to all F1 teams Plus

The time-honoured manufacturer model that can't apply to all F1 teams

What happens, asks MATT KEW, if the old adage of win on a Sunday, sell on a Monday is no longer true for F1 manufacturers?

Why is Oscar Piastri F1's most sought-after rookie? Plus

Why is Oscar Piastri F1's most sought-after rookie?

The Australian rising star is fast, consistent, confident, adaptable and has shown excellent racecraft, but there’s already a taint to his reputation. That hasn’t stopped him becoming the hottest property in this year’s F1 driver market and why McLaren moved fast to snap up the 21-year-old

Formula 1
Sep 30, 2022
The unintended benefit that F1's new engine rules era will deliver Plus

The unintended benefit that F1's new engine rules era will deliver

Formula 1's incoming engine rules shake-up has multiple targets. But it may also solve what has been a bone of contention since the hybrids arrived in 2014. The new plan will allow the series to pump up the volume

Formula 1
Sep 29, 2022
How de Vries made himself impossible to ignore for a belated F1 chance Plus

How de Vries made himself impossible to ignore for a belated F1 chance

Nyck de Vries appeared to have missed his opportunity to break into Formula 1 as he was passed over for more exciting talents who have now become frontrunners and title fighters. But after catching the eye outside of the F1 sphere, before his stunning impromptu grand prix debut in Italy, will it lead to a delayed full-time race seat?

Formula 1
Sep 29, 2022
Can Hamilton produce another Singapore magic moment? Plus

Can Hamilton produce another Singapore magic moment?

The Singapore Grand Prix has, explains BEN EDWARDS, played an important role in Lewis Hamilton’s Formula 1 career. As the series returns to the Marina Bay Street Circuit for the first time in three years, he faces the latest challenge with an underperforming Mercedes car

Formula 1
Sep 28, 2022
Why Sainz is key to Ferrari achieving its chairman's F1 goals Plus

Why Sainz is key to Ferrari achieving its chairman's F1 goals

Although Ferrari's chances of title glory in 2022 have evaporated, chairman John Elkann expects the team to have chalked up both championships by 2026. Both require drivers to play the team game and, having now become more comfortable with the F1-75, Carlos Sainz may be Ferrari's key to title glory

Formula 1
Sep 27, 2022
How F1 has tried to avoid repeating its 2014 engine rules mistakes Plus

How F1 has tried to avoid repeating its 2014 engine rules mistakes

With Formula 1’s future engine regulations now agreed, MARK GALLAGHER wonders if they will provide a more competitive field than past attempts actually managed

Formula 1
Sep 26, 2022
How its faltering first turbo car advanced a Williams-Honda glory era Plus

How its faltering first turbo car advanced a Williams-Honda glory era

STUART CODLING charts the development of the Williams FW09, the ugly duckling that heralded the start of the title-winning Williams-Honda partnership

Formula 1
Sep 25, 2022