The club racing initiative that should be dropped post-COVID

Online scrutineering was a neat solution to minimise contact as club racing returned in 2020, but should it be left behind when the world returns to normal? STEFAN MACKLEY argues that in the interests of safety and transparency, it should be quietly dropped

The club racing initiative that should be dropped post-COVID

When club racing finally got underway last season under the shadow of the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a small sense that normality had returned - even if we were, and still are, some way off that.

Racing began in July - three months later than planned - with a raft of changes to ensure that competitors, officials and marshals were kept as safe as possible from catching the dreaded virus.

One of the pivotal changes was the introduction of online scrutineering, both for a driver's safety equipment and their car, to limit contact between people. It was seen by many as a welcome addition to club motorsport, even something which should have been introduced years ago.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, as it meant there was no need for competitors to begrudgingly rise early in the morning and trudge across to the scrutineering bay in the cold to have their pride and joy checked for the umpteenth time. But with COVID restrictions hopefully being eased in the near future - and this time for good - is keeping online scrutineering the right direction for club motorsport?

There's certainly advantages to keeping it, with the above-mentioned time saving being one of them. The more rigorous scrutineering could still be implemented for top-level national championships that form stepping stones for aspiring career drivers or carry significant prize pots.

But it's less crucial for the average club series - is it really necessary for the driver often battling for 29th place in a 40-car Toyota MR2 field to head to scrutineering before every event? Many reading this might argue not, but there are two distinct reasons why getting up early to have your car checked is no bad thing.

As with anything - even club motorsport - competitors will always look for the 'unfair advantage'. It won't be the majority of them, but those intent on winning at almost all costs, and who have the budgets to match, will take advantage wherever possible. This is still racing at the end of the day, whether it's a small club meeting or Formula 1.

It's down to the honesty of the competitor to make sure that what they are saying about both vehicle and driver equipment is correct. And while the vast majority will do that, there's always the few who let the side down

While some will look to gain a competitive advantage, it's from a safety standpoint where on-the-day scrutineering is perhaps most vital. Motorsport is expensive and wherever money can be saved - or corners cut - someone will look to do it, whether by not having a rollcage correctly fitted into the car or self-declaring that their helmet or race suit is of a certain FIA homologation.

Having taken part in one event last year that required self-scrutineering, it really is down to the honesty of the competitor to make sure that what they are saying about both vehicle and driver equipment is correct. And while the vast majority will do that, there's always the few who let the side down.

INSIGHT: Club racing with an ex-Formula 1 driver

It might not even be a deliberate act which means a vehicle is unsafe, but more a case of a competitor finding themselves a little out of their depth when building their own machine and incorrectly fitting a rollcage or other safety feature.

It could be argued that once the threat of COVID is deemed insignificant - although quite when that will be is anyone's guess - that spot-checks could increase and organisers could coordinate these to ensure that every full-season entrant's car is thoroughly examined at least once a season.

The process of checking the top three finishers after a race or perhaps the top three in the standings before the event starts could also be formalised. Last year, different organisers put in place various scrutineering procedures, but a prescriptive minimum standard could be set out to give competitors peace of mind.

Increasing the number of spot-checks and coming down harder on those who deliberately flaunt the regulations are certainly ways of combatting rulebreakers but, without each car being scrutinised every weekend, there will always be one or two that get through the cracks.

And what would the consequences be to UK motorsport should a competitor whose machine wasn't up to the task be involved in an incident that leaves drivers, marshals or even spectators with serious injuries or worse?

While the preparation standard of cars is high at the moment and the days of 'rust buckets' are behind us, should online scrutineering be adopted long-term then it could prove a slippery slope...

shares
comments
Club motorsport to restart in England from 29 March as roadmap released

Previous article

Club motorsport to restart in England from 29 March as roadmap released

Next article

Goodwood Members' Meeting postponed from May to October

Goodwood Members' Meeting postponed from May to October
Load comments

About this article

Series National
Author Stefan Mackley
How 2020's newest national series and championships fared Plus

How 2020's newest national series and championships fared

To the credit of organisers, some new national UK series and championships were still able to successfully launch last year, even with the world in the grip of a pandemic. Here's how Autosport has ranked them

National
Feb 14, 2021
The new national series and championships in 2021 Plus

The new national series and championships in 2021

The COVID-19 pandemic may still mean there is uncertainty across the globe, but that hasn't stopped new series and championships from being introduced into UK motorsport this season. Autosport takes a look at the newest additions

National
Feb 10, 2021
The verdict on how COVID impacted club racing in 2020 Plus

The verdict on how COVID impacted club racing in 2020

It was a season like no other but, despite the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic, there were some positives on the club motorsport scene last year as entry numbers largely remained stable, while some series boasted impressive growth

National
Feb 7, 2021
How a Porsche King became 2020's breakout star Plus

How a Porsche King became 2020's breakout star

Few drivers in 2020 could lay claim to a season as exceptional as Porsche Carrera Cup GB champion Harry King. Beating the British Touring Car Championship's best to win Autosport's National Driver of the Year was the ideal recognition of his feat

National
Feb 1, 2021
The Formula Vee maverick who has reached the top Plus

The Formula Vee maverick who has reached the top

For a second consecutive year, a self-built machine has won the Formula Vee championship. But James Harridge's 'Maverick' comes from the very humblest of origins - with some parts even salvaged from a skip

National
Jan 24, 2021
The greatest club racing characters Plus

The greatest club racing characters

From legendary drinking habits to dramatic driving styles, there has been no shortage of cult-hero figures over the past 70 years in national motorsport. Here's an extended version of the original list that appeared in Autosport's 70th anniversary bookazine

National
Jan 5, 2021
The reboot behind the UK’s thriving single-seater category Plus

The reboot behind the UK’s thriving single-seater category

The long-standing British Formula 3 Championship ended in 2014, but the current MotorSport Vision-run F3 series has gone some way to filling the void. In striving to keep costs down, it's carved out a niche that it hopes will attract aspirational drivers

National
Jan 2, 2021
The UK series where F1's pioneers made their mark Plus

The UK series where F1's pioneers made their mark

Before the likes of Colin Chapman, Gordon Murray and Patrick Head became fixtures of the Formula 1 paddock, they all cut their teeth in the UK's now longest running championship - which is still going strong despite 2020's global pandemic

National
Dec 30, 2020