Puig hits back at Michelin MotoGP chief over Indonesia tyre comments

Honda MotoGP boss Alberto Puig has hit back at comments made by Michelin surrounding the tyre problems it suffered in last weekend’s Indonesian Grand Prix.

Puig hits back at Michelin MotoGP chief over Indonesia tyre comments

After the standard 2022 tyres suffered blistering in February’s pre-season test at the Mandalika circuit due to the extreme heat, Michelin elected to bring a stiffer tyre construction not used since 2018.

While most felt the older tyre design generally offered less grip, these problems affected Honda – who topped the Mandalika test on the standard tyre – the most.

Pol Espargaro was worried he wouldn’t be able to finish the race due to the stress being put on the front tyre as a result of his lack of rear grip, while Marc Marquez suffered a horrifying highside in the warm-up session which ruled him out of the race and has led to more double vision problems.

After the race, Puig said Honda had to understand what went on with Michelin – though the latter insisted “there was no problem” with the tyres in Indonesia and suggested Honda simply didn’t know how to get it to work.

In a lengthy statement issued to Autosport from Honda, Puig feels Michelin boss Piero Taramasso’s comments were “not necessary”.

“Well, speaking frankly, and in my personal and own opinion – I am not very surprised,” Puig said of Taramasso’s comments.

“In my last Track Report, I only mentioned that we would have to analyse the situation with Michelin – that’s all.

“And we see how Mr Taramasso reacted when prompted by the media - it was not necessary at all...

“It’s a bit strange when he says, in a polite way of course, that Honda doesn’t know how to adapt.

“Honda has been adapting to many technical changes, including different regulations, tyres, engine sizes, classes, etc. etc. since the beginning of the world championship series back in 1966 and it has been the longest lasting and most successful company in GP history with 25 premier class constructor championships and 21 premier class rider world championships.

“Does this mean we don’t know how to adapt? OK, it’s the first I’m hearing this.”

Michelin says its findings on the tyres were based on its own data analysis, but Puig believes in instances like this rider opinion means more than “a line on a computer”, while noting that Taramasso “has a mentality” to “not admit any error”.

“From my own experience in racing, you have to talk to the riders first – not to Apple, IBM or Dell where you see a line on a computer,” he added.

“You must listen to the riders and if you have riders that have been world champions, multiple times, you can assume that these riders are guys who know what they are talking about.

“In this paddock, manufacturers talk to manufacturers, riders talk to the organiser, IRTA (International Race Teams Association) talks to the teams and many times we disagree on many subjects.

Marc Marquez, Repsol Honda Team

Marc Marquez, Repsol Honda Team

Photo by: Gold and Goose / Motorsport Images

“But it is always in the limits of discussions and debate where we evolve and find good solutions that allow us to move forward in the interest of all parties and of the sport. Mr Taramasso looks to have a mentality that every time someone talks directly about his tyres, he becomes hypersensitive, not admitting any error from his side and this, from my perspective, is wrong and too radical.

“We all make mistakes, him as well.”

One of Taramasso’s complaints stemmed from Puig not having been at the February test to understand the tyre issues.

Puig – who was undergoing surgery at the time of the test – thinks his experience as a rider gives him a good understanding of situations like this, and highlighted the fact that the carcass Michelin brought to Indonesia was designed for a completely different type of circuit layout.

“My understanding, or apparent lack thereof, that Mr Taramasso mentions is clearly not precise,” Puig stated.

“For Mr Taramasso’s information – I was racing for many years and even had a few really good races back in the 1990s, with Michelin tyres by the way.

“So, I understand very well what a rider feels and needs from a tyre when they are racing a machine that produces over 200 bhp.

“In fact, you can only understand a racing tyre if you have raced.

“If you are in the office or in front of a computer you can understand some things, the theory, but you can never understand the reality, the feeling of what a racing slick tyre is.

“The tyre Michelin brought for the Indonesian GP was used in Thailand and Austria a few years ago (2017/2018), tracks that have long straights.

“Mandalika is a completely different circuit, it’s a track where you do not have many long straights and where the bike is nearly always carrying some lean angle or with some banking.

“These kinds of tracks need good edge grip, you clearly don’t need a rock-hard tyre at this type of track.

“This older carcass had, and has, its own issues especially around getting the tyre up to temperature.

“We can see that during the Mandalika weekend most of the crashes were in the first two laps – a problem that was common with this 2018 tyre and why Michelin developed new tyres.

“Furthermore, you must develop a MotoGP machine around the tyres of that season, so when you change the tyres suddenly to one which the bike was not designed for, it complicates the situation a lot for all teams. Honda were not the only manufacturer to find their riders’ pace and feeling suddenly gone during the Indonesian GP weekend.”

Due to the Mandalika track breaking up at the last corner, the MotoGP race was shortened from 27 laps to 20.

Puig believes this could have been an option in the first place to get around the tyre blistering problem from the test, while also suggesting a flag-to-flag contest in the dry – as was the case in Australia in 2013 and Argentina in 2016 when tyre issues prompted safety concerns.

He also felt a misinterpretation of his riders’ comments about the age of the tyre by Taramasso was “not very respectful to them”.

While Marquez’s warm-up crash was a result of the rear of his Honda letting go through Turn 7 in the warm-up session ahead of the race, Puig insists that he doesn’t believe at this stage Michelin is fully to blame for the incident.

Marc Marquez, Repsol Honda Team after his crash

Marc Marquez, Repsol Honda Team after his crash

Photo by: Gold and Goose / Motorsport Images

“No, absolutely not,” he concluded when asked if Marquez’s crash was entirely the tyre’s fault.

“I never said that, I said that we must understand the situation fully and talk to Michelin for clarity and to understand what the plan is in case this kind of situation happens again.

Read Also:

“But Mr Taramasso has overreacted to my words. I’ve always considered Michelin to be a very technically advanced company, an industry leader in the development of racing tyres for both cars and bikes.

“They are experts in competition and have spent many years working for and achieving massive success in their field and have produced very good materials throughout these years of racing.

“I have been involved in racing for many years and with this have been able to understand that when a rider crashes and there is no clear mechanical problem then it is a rider mistake.

“But in all crashes, there are elements that contribute to the crash and tyres are a part of the equation.

“If Mr Taramasso cannot understand or accept this, then I do not understand his mentality or approach.

“You know, there are many people in this paddock that talk all day, constantly talking about everything.

“This is not my case, I don’t talk a lot, I only talk when I am asked to talk or when I have something to say.

“The situation in Mandalika is such a case and the only thing I said was that we had to talk deeply with Michelin.

“That is the point. There has been an almost unbelievable reaction to wanting to further understand the situation.

“Mr Taramasso must understand that if some of my riders have some problems or doubts about anything regarding our bike, it is my job, my responsibility, as team manager to investigate the issue and give solutions to my riders.

“I understand this is my job, I do it this way and I will not change.”

shares
comments
The signs KTM has turned around the MotoGP bike Marquez can't understand
Previous article

The signs KTM has turned around the MotoGP bike Marquez can't understand

Next article

Marquez to miss Argentina MotoGP round after Mandalika crash

Marquez to miss Argentina MotoGP round after Mandalika crash
The signs the old Marquez is really back to trouble his MotoGP rivals Plus

The signs the old Marquez is really back to trouble his MotoGP rivals

OPINION: Marc Marquez has completed the first three races of his MotoGP comeback from a fourth major operation on his right arm and has already achieved more points than Honda scored in his absence. While there is still some way to go before he is ready to win races, there have been plenty of signs to suggest that the old Marquez really is back

MotoGP
Oct 4, 2022
The talent-outweighing ambition that will kill Ducati’s 2022 MotoGP title hopes Plus

The talent-outweighing ambition that will kill Ducati’s 2022 MotoGP title hopes

OPINION: For the fourth time in 2022, Francesco Bagnaia has made a costly error while battling other riders. Crashing while chasing one point at the Japanese Grand Prix has lost him eight to a struggling Fabio Quartararo. With just four rounds remaining and a history of errors in high-pressure situations, Bagnaia and Ducati need a serious rethink to stop its best opportunity of a title in 15 years slipping away

MotoGP
Sep 26, 2022
The unique advantage Ducati must now use to win the 2022 MotoGP title Plus

The unique advantage Ducati must now use to win the 2022 MotoGP title

Ducati has littered the grid with eight strong motorcycles that has ensured it has had at least one rider stand on the podium at every grand prix in 2022. The drama of the Aragon Grand Prix has thrust Francesco Bagnaia well and truly into title contention with five races to go, and Ducati must now consider utilising a unique strength it has so far been reticent to embrace

MotoGP
Sep 19, 2022
How KTM failed one of its brightest MotoGP prospects Plus

How KTM failed one of its brightest MotoGP prospects

Reigning Moto2 champion Remy Gardner’s career has been derailed by KTM’s decision not to retain him at Tech3 for 2023. Amid difficult circumstances, Gardner hasn’t shamed himself. But KTM’s apparent reasoning for dropping him raises questions about its handling of its young riders and the unrealistic expectations placed on them

MotoGP
Sep 6, 2022
Why it won’t just be Marquez’s speed that saves Honda in MotoGP Plus

Why it won’t just be Marquez’s speed that saves Honda in MotoGP

OPINION: Honda is in the midst of a second winless season in the space of three years. The absence of the injured Marc Marquez has been a major contributing factor, but HRC’s inability to alter its own approach has seen it slide down the order. Marquez returned to the MotoGP paddock in Austria and provided a rallying cry Honda needed to hear.

MotoGP
Aug 22, 2022
The signs Quartararo’s 2022 MotoGP title is slipping away from him Plus

The signs Quartararo’s 2022 MotoGP title is slipping away from him

Prior to the summer break, the 2022 MotoGP title looked like it was Fabio Quartararo’s to lose. But a crash at Assen and the consequential penalty he had to serve last weekend at Silverstone stopped him from capitalising on a main rival’s injury woes, while a resurgence from another, plus the rise of a former team-mate, look set to conspire against the Yamaha rider

MotoGP
Aug 8, 2022
Why Marquez’s toughest MotoGP foe is stopping at the right time Plus

Why Marquez’s toughest MotoGP foe is stopping at the right time

On the eve of the British Grand Prix, Andrea Dovizioso announced that he will be retiring from MotoGP after September’s San Marino GP. The timing of his departure raised eyebrows, but his reasoning remains sensible and what has happened this year should not diminish a hard-built legacy

MotoGP
Aug 6, 2022
Why a Suzuki refugee feels he deserves MotoGP's toughest challenge Plus

Why a Suzuki refugee feels he deserves MotoGP's toughest challenge

Alex Rins’ MotoGP future was plunged into sudden doubt when Suzuki elected to quit the series at the end of 2022. Securing a deal with Honda to join LCR, he will now tread a path that many have fallen off from. But it was a move he felt his status deserved, and it’s a challenge – he tells Autosport - he faces with his eyes wide open…

MotoGP
Jul 27, 2022