Formula E team bosses defend qualifying strategy after first group issues

Leading Formula E team bosses have defended their strategy and explained why the points leaders tripped over each other to qualify down the order for the inaugural Puebla E-Prix.

Formula E team bosses defend qualifying strategy after first group issues

The current qualifying format puts the top six in the points at an inherent disadvantage by sending them first out onto a green track surface that does not readily offer up lap time.

But the comparatively slow times of Antonio Felix da Costa (13th fastest), Mitch Evans (14th), Nyck de Vries (16th), Robin Frijns (22nd) and Stoffel Vandoorne (23rd) were exacerbated.

The drivers ran two- and three-wide even until the final corner of their out-lap in a fight for track position. Subsequent lock ups for Frijns and Mercedes driver Vandoorne into Turn 1, plus an attempted pass on Vandoorne from Bird, further delayed the frontrunners.

Da Costa, fastest from the group one entry, was still 1.3s slower than group two pacesetter and eventual polesitter Pascal Wehrlein.

But Mercedes team principal Ian James defended the events, which drew criticism on social media and unfolded in similar style to qualifying for the fifth of the six Berlin races last year.

He told Autosport: "It's the nature of the qualifying, or the format that we've got at the moment.

“That's combined with this particular circuit, where it's clear everybody is going to be following a very similar strategy.

“Unfortunately, we all put ourselves in a position where you're tripping over each other.”

Nyck de Vries, Mercedes Benz EQ, EQ Silver Arrow 02

Nyck de Vries, Mercedes Benz EQ, EQ Silver Arrow 02

Photo by: Sam Bloxham / Motorsport Images

Asked by Autosport whether it would have been worth the risk to leave the garage earlier in a bid to find clear air or to have set a banker lap to run on circuit out of sequence, James added: “You can avoid that by going out much earlier.

“But then there's the whole question about track evolution.

“Every time it's a roll of the dice.

“Unfortunately, as we saw today, it had certainly a detrimental impact.”

James also defended teams not calling for their drivers to back off in the final corner of their out-lap, while effectively battling for position, in a bid to find space.

He said: "It was a combination of factors that we had there.

“Obviously, we had the issue with a couple of the other cars having a problem going into Turn 1.

“Prior to that, so before we actually started the lap, they were on the limit from a time perspective [to cross the line before the countdown elapses].

“That's when it comes back to the fact that if everybody's leaving it to the last minute to try and get an advantage, it's going to end in tears.

“That's what we've seen again today.”

Autosport understands that very light rain through the final sector had been exaggerated by residual moisture from the showers on Friday rising back through the asphalt to leave puddles.

Maximilian Gunther, BMW i Andretti Motorsport, BMW iFE.21, Sam Bird, Jaguar Racing, Jaguar I-TYPE 5

Maximilian Gunther, BMW i Andretti Motorsport, BMW iFE.21, Sam Bird, Jaguar Racing, Jaguar I-TYPE 5

Photo by: Simon Galloway / Motorsport Images

Jaguar Racing team principal James Barclay added: “Obviously people are asking, 'Why is it so close like that?'.

“We always knew coming to here that track evolution would be a lot. No one wanted to be first on the road to sweep it.

“It's really tough and that's why we do need to look at the quali format going forward. As a world championship now, you want to see the best teams, the best cars, best drivers fighting at the front.”

Autosport understands the current Formula E group qualifying format will be replaced in time for the Gen3 era starting in 2022-23.

This comes as the championship wants to move away from its much-billed ‘unpredictable’ nature to instead create established stars who can win regularly.

shares
comments

Related video

Buemi set for grid penalty to solve “fundamental” Nissan e.dams car woes

Previous article

Buemi set for grid penalty to solve “fundamental” Nissan e.dams car woes

Next article

Puebla E-Prix: Di Grassi leads Audi 1-2 after Porsche's Wehrlein disqualified

Puebla E-Prix: Di Grassi leads Audi 1-2 after Porsche's Wehrlein disqualified
Load comments
Why Audi was right and wrong in Formula E's loophole row Plus

Why Audi was right and wrong in Formula E's loophole row

OPINION: With Audi's Formula E exit imminent, it had nothing to lose in London by attempting to vault Lucas di Grassi into the lead by pitting him under the safety car. Scorn directed at the team for putting glory before ethics should instead be pointed at a rulebook that allowed such a move in the first place

Why Formula E's London return delivered anarchy in the UK Plus

Why Formula E's London return delivered anarchy in the UK

Formula E landed for a London E-Prix for the first time since 2016, at the indoor-outdoor circuit around the ExCeL. Featuring the birth of renewed title pushes, a long-awaited maiden win and the second race's controversy, the round proved to be an exhibition of the electric series' anarchic nature

Formula E
Jul 26, 2021
Why consistency can't be relied upon for Formula E title success Plus

Why consistency can't be relied upon for Formula E title success

It's commonly upheld as the most straightforward method of racking up titles. But, due to the unique qualifying format used in Formula E, a consistent approach can actively work against a driver and make their life harder in races. So with four races to go, is now the time to ditch the tried-and-tested approach for a win-or-bust mentality?

Formula E
Jul 23, 2021
How Bird's crash recovery became Formula E's fairytale of New York Plus

How Bird's crash recovery became Formula E's fairytale of New York

After crashing in practice during the opening session at the New York City E-Prix, Sam Bird immediately had a recovery job on his hands. But the Jaguar driver rose through the order and secured victory in the second race - and with it, the championship lead. Here's how an Englishman in New York became top of the heap

Formula E
Jul 12, 2021
Why Formula E is plotting a major change of philosophy Plus

Why Formula E is plotting a major change of philosophy

Formula E has become famed for its unpredictability, which can yield exciting races - but it can be argued that it robs the all-electric championship of a clear narrative and doesn't adequately reward the best drivers. The series wants to change that, and renew its philosophy ahead of the introduction of its next-generation car

Formula E
Jun 29, 2021
How Puebla's high-altitude encounter gave Formula E's new leader breathing space Plus

How Puebla's high-altitude encounter gave Formula E's new leader breathing space

With the usual Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez venue unavailable to Formula E, it visited the little Puebla circuit to keep its foot in the door in Mexico. A near-winner two years ago, Pascal Wehrlein looked in swaggering form throughout the weekend - but a breathless final encounter helped put Edoardo Mortara in the driving seat

Formula E
Jun 21, 2021
The half-term report cards of each Formula E team in 2020-21 Plus

The half-term report cards of each Formula E team in 2020-21

In an eventful Formula E season, punctuated by rain and energy-conservation controversy, the 12 teams contesting the championship have endured many challenges in the opening seven races. Here's how they've got on across the first half of the season.

Formula E
May 26, 2021
How Formula E stood up to F1 comparisons in Monaco Plus

How Formula E stood up to F1 comparisons in Monaco

OPINION: It was no surprise to anybody that the laptimes achieved by Formula E cars on the full Monaco circuit were much slower than Formula 1. But perhaps the more relevant comparison was in the racing spectacle, where FE delivered in spades

Formula E
May 12, 2021