Skip to main content

Sign up for free

  • Get quick access to your favorite articles

  • Manage alerts on breaking news and favorite drivers

  • Make your voice heard with article commenting.

Autosport Plus

Discover premium content
Subscribe

Recommended for you

Colton Herta, Cadillac F1 Team

What has Cadillac got to lose by picking Herta?

Both team and driver have sunk a great deal of time, money and effort into getting Colton Herta ready to race in Formula 1. Now is the time to make a decision

Formula 1 waits for nobody.

In 2019, Colton Herta became the youngest-ever IndyCar race winner at 18 years, 11 months and 25 days. And yet here he is now, 26 years old and still regarded – by the Formula 1 paddock at least – as somebody who still has to eat their lunch with a spoon.

It’s been a tormented journey ever since then, one which has taken Herta from being IndyCar’s hottest young star to just about scraping through the F1 superlicence qualification rubric. In terms of over-promising and under-delivering within that timeframe, perhaps we’re not quite in the same territory as Prince Harry and Meghan Markle doing a $20million podcast deal with Spotify and then only laying down 12 episodes. Unless there really are millions of Herta fans out there waiting breathlessly to see whether Colton really does get an F1 seat or if the story ends there.

But getting an American driver into F1 is one of the Cadillac team’s mandates, and CEO Dan Towriss has been among Herta’s keenest supporters, backing him in IndyCar via the Andretti Autosport organisation since 2020.

"We're committed to having an American driver," Towriss told reporters at last year’s Miami Grand Prix. "It's important to all of us to do it the right way. It's not a gimmick to just grab somebody and drop them in the seat – because it's important to us that they're successful.

"We want that seat respected when that American driver does come in for the team. We're committed to that and we'll find the right way and the right time to bring the right driver into Formula 1."

Herta's best IndyCar championship finish was second in 2024

Herta's best IndyCar championship finish was second in 2024

Photo by: Getty Images

Herta’s chief obstacle has been the qualifying rubric for an F1 superlicence. In 2022 he briefly entered the frame at the team then known as AlphaTauri as a putative replacement for the Alpine-bound Pierre Gasly. His ability appeared to be one of the few issues Christian Horner and Helmut Marko agreed upon, since Horner described him as "an exciting talent" in the wake of Marko telling the Sirius XM radio outlet that he’d done a deal to bring Herta to F1. That foundered because Herta didn’t have enough superlicence points, despite being a seven-time winner in the IndyCar series.

Towriss persuaded Herta to remain in IndyCar but, having taken a more prominent role in the project to bring Cadillac to the F1 grid, he sanctioned Herta’s move to Formula 2 this season in a bid to accrue the necessary points. In an unfortunate piece of timing, the FIA then remapped the point system to be less disadvantageous to IndyCar drivers. Still, Herta had only accrued two podium finishes in 2025 and finished seventh overall, a disappointing follow-up to 2024, where he claimed two more victories on his way to being the championship runner-up.

At the time of writing, Herta lies 19th in F2 after scoring points in just five races, but has now completed enough 'rookie runs' in a Cadillac F1 car during FP1 sessions that he meets the superlicence threshold. On the face of it, Herta’s F2 campaign hasn’t been a stellar advert for his abilities, but that category is now a notoriously unreliable gauge of talent.

If both Cadillac’s F1 drivers had been performing consistently through the season there would be no question over whether Valtteri Bottas should be retained alongside Sergio Perez, who recently extended his contract. But while the cars themselves have been blighted by recurring performance and reliability issues, Perez has conspicuously outperformed Bottas for most of the season – had the Singapore GP run five minutes longer, for example, Perez would have lapped him.

On this evidence you could reasonably argue that, all other factors being equal, replacing Bottas with Herta wouldn’t lead to a measurably worse championship outcome. The team has yet to score a point so far this season, despite closing the gap to the midfield.

But Towriss and his partners have loftier ambitions for the team, as evinced by the surprise axing this summer of Graeme Lowdon, who had superintended Cadillac’s preparations for joining F1. It’s understood that one of the key reasons for making such a drastic change to the team’s senior management was a fundamental disparity in outlook: Lowdon, along with much of the F1 paddock, was of the view that the team had done very well just to get two functioning cars on the grid, while Towriss and the other stakeholders thought qualifying at the back wasn’t good enough.

Perez thrilled his home crowd in Mexico City with a street display - and a contract extension

Perez thrilled his home crowd in Mexico City with a street display - and a contract extension

Photo by: Bernardo Maldonado 

In this context, Bottas still probably isn’t the man for the job – but Herta is a fringe candidate.

The team’s ownership structure also remains in question owing to a Securities and Exchange Commission investigation into the billionaire financier Mark Walter, whose TWG Global entity is a partner with General Motors in the enterprise. Although the official line is that the team isn’t up for sale, it’s understood that potential investors are at least in talks to acquire Walter’s stake, including the Fenway Sports Group, which also owns the Liverpool FC.

What’s not likely to change is the ambition of the organisation to be a properly American team, rather than a European-based outfit flying a flag of convenience. A new factory is approaching completion in a suburb of Indianapolis, while the GM Performance Power Units joint venture is ramping up to begin its own F1 engine project in a new facility in Charlotte, North Carolina, this December.

So one of the key questions is one of timing: American driver now or later? Cadillac’s target is to have its own engine for the start of 2029, which will be the final season of Perez’s contract. This, the point where Cadillac can claim with full rigour to be an all-American team, would seem a logical deadline for a US-born driver to have entered the mix as team leader. Given the investment in Herta’s career so far, and the absence of other options apart from another season in F2 or a return to IndyCar, now is the time to give him an opportunity to demonstrate potential.

It’s either that or let him go entirely, because Herta’s reputation is on the wane. Noticeably, when our Motorsport.com colleague Luis Ramirez joined a select gathering to interview former Alpine and Force India team principal Otmar Szafnauer in Mexico, Herta ranked only as an afterthought in the question of who might replace Bottas at Cadillac.

"If they don't keep Bottas, I would take a young driver who has good potential," said Szafnauer. "And the reason I say that is that Checo [Perez] is capable of showing you where the limits of the car are. And with the young guy next to him, you can already start preparing him for three years' time, when Checo is no longer there or when he retires, and get him up to speed.

FP1 run in Sao Paulo got Herta over the line in terms of superlicence points

FP1 run in Sao Paulo got Herta over the line in terms of superlicence points

Photo by: James Sutton / Formula 1 / Formula Motorsport Ltd via Getty Images

"I would take a Tsolov, a Lawson, or a Lindblad. I would take one of them. Because what you don't want is for neither of the two drivers to be able to show you how good the car is. And once you have one of them, you might as well develop someone in the other seat. Especially if you're Cadillac.

"Perhaps Colton is not the right man; that's for them to decide. I like Colton, but you need someone with huge potential. If there's another Kimi Antonelli out there, I would take him."

Has Herta’s opportunity has already passed? He may not be Cadillac’s Mr Right. But, for now, he could be Mr You’ll Do – and in the absence of other compelling options, that could be enough.

Read Also:
Previous article Haas sticks with Camara for Las Vegas GP, Hirakawa in for FP1

Top Comments

More from Stuart Codling

Latest news