Analysis: The drama at Indianapolis Motor Speedway

IndyCar is learning about its new, manufacturer-developed aero kits in public, while a series of high-speed aerial accidents overshadow the build-up to its centrepiece, the Indianapolis 500

Analysis: The drama at Indianapolis Motor Speedway

Whether the kits have played any role in any of the accidents remains to be seen, but there are lessons to be learned, writes AUTOSPORT's IndyCar correspondent MARK GLENDENNING.

Frank Gardner used to tell a story about testing the Porsche 917. The laconic Australian racer and engineer would return to the pits after a run in a car that was, by all accounts, terrifying to drive in its early iterations, and would be swarmed by German engineers looking for feedback.

He'd explain what he'd felt the car doing, and the engineers would often interject with the readings they were getting: "Well, the computer says that the car's doing this..."

This began to wear thin with Gardner, and when the computer was mentioned once too often, the last threads of his patience finally snapped:

"The bloody computer isn't sitting there doing 300km/h with its arse an inch off the ground."

Computer simulations were in their infancy then, but even so, his basic point still rings true today: there's only so much that you can learn about a racecar without putting it onto a track.

Hinchcliffe recovering in intensive care following practice crash

And that's becoming a lesson that IndyCar is learning the hard way.

Whether you're a fan of the manufacturer-designed aero kits or not, the implementation has not been smooth.

The first race at St Petersburg was a chaotic debris-fest that ended with a spectator being hospitalised with a skull fracture after taking a piece of carbon fibre to the head.

And now, the build up to the Indy 500 - far and away the most important weekend in IndyCar's year - has been overshadowed by a string of huge accidents

IndyCar is yet to establish a definitive link between any of the crashes and the new aero kits.

The impact that left James Hinchcliffe in hospital certainly had nothing to do with his bodywork, and nor did Pippa Mann's accident earlier in the week.

Where the aerial shunts involving Helio Castroneves, Josef Newgarden and Ed Carpenter are concerned, the jury is still out. Even those three had different root causes, it's the bit where the car launches into the air that is the focus.

The precautionary measures that the series took ahead of qualifying last weekend, when it lowered the engine power and mandated that cars race in the aero configuration that they qualify with - effectively forcing everyone to qualify in race trim - were reasonable given the circumstances.

But there is going to be increasing scrutiny over how these circumstances were allowed to develop in the first place.

Only six days of two-car track testing were permitted to each manufacturer during the development of the kits, and every new unanswered question is making that allocation look incrementally inadequate.

Why don't more F1 drivers do the Indy 500?

And the series' reaction to the situation has been poor.

It took five days and three crashes before IndyCar offered an official response, and that was more than enough time for it to lose any hope of controlling the narrative. In PR terms, that's a disaster.

In time, IndyCar and its manufacturers will figure out whether there's a common ingredient to any of those crashes, and if measures are needed, they'll be swiftly taken. The series tends to be good like that.

But that doesn't solve the problem of how the series allowed itself to get into the position, and this is becoming a recurring theme with IndyCar.

The shambolic return to Houston a couple of years ago was inevitable as soon as someone signed off on a contract that gave the promoter just a few days to build an entire circuit.

Anyone who watched F1 in the late 1990s would have wondered about the fragility of Chevrolet's soon-to-be-banned front wing uppers when they appeared at St Petersburg.

And, as Frank Gardner shows us, we've known for decades that computers are useful tools, but mere tools nonetheless.

Qualifying weekend for the world's biggest race should not be the first time that a series starts to wonder whether an aero package has some sneaky problem that the simulations didn't spot.


I hope that the current investigations conclude that the aero kit was blameless, because IndyCar can only absorb so many blows to its credibility.

The series has done a fantastic job in so many respects to restore itself over the past few years, and yet its propensity to keep stepping on rakes beggars belief.

And if the aero kit is indeed a non-factor, then I hope that IndyCar still treats the past week as an opportunity to learn a few lessons, both in how to introduce a major technical change, and in how to stop a story from ballooning out of its control.

But most of all, I just really hope that when I'm writing AUTOSPORT's race report for the 500 on Sunday afternoon, the only thing I'm thinking about is the amazing spectacle that I just witnessed.

The Indianapolis 500 deserves no less.

shares
comments
Hinchcliffe recovering in intensive care following practice crash

Previous article

Hinchcliffe recovering in intensive care following practice crash

Next article

Why don't more F1 drivers do the Indy 500?

Why don't more F1 drivers do the Indy 500?
Load comments
Remembering Dan Wheldon and his last and most amazing IndyCar win Plus

Remembering Dan Wheldon and his last and most amazing IndyCar win

Saturday 16 October marks the 10th anniversary of Dan Wheldon’s death. David Malsher-Lopez pays tribute, then asks Wheldon’s race engineer from 2011, Todd Malloy, to recall that magical second victory at the Indianapolis 500

Why Kyle Kirkwood is America's new IndyCar ace-in-waiting Plus

Why Kyle Kirkwood is America's new IndyCar ace-in-waiting

Kyle Kirkwood, the record-setting junior formula driver, sealed the Indy Lights championship last weekend. But despite an absurdly strong junior career and scholarship money, his next move is far from clear

IndyCar
Oct 6, 2021
Why IndyCar title glory is just the start for Ganassi's new star Plus

Why IndyCar title glory is just the start for Ganassi's new star

Newly-crowned IndyCar champion Alex Palou has been lauded as a complete driver and veteran-like in only his second season. The 24-year-old is still in the early days of his career, but the parallels are there for all to see with his six-time champion Chip Ganassi Racing team-mate who has been CGR's team leader since 2014

IndyCar
Sep 28, 2021
Why Grosjean's oval commitment shows he's serious about IndyCar Plus

Why Grosjean's oval commitment shows he's serious about IndyCar

One of motorsport’s worst-kept secrets is now out in the open, and Romain Grosjean has been confirmed as an Andretti Autosport IndyCar driver in 2022. It marks a remarkable turnaround after the abrupt end to his Formula 1 career, and is a firm indication of his commitment to challenge for the IndyCar Series title  

IndyCar
Sep 24, 2021
Why IndyCar’s longest silly-season is still far from over Plus

Why IndyCar’s longest silly-season is still far from over

OPINION: The 2021 IndyCar silly season has been one of the silliest for many years, as many talented drivers remain in play – with new pieces to the puzzle being added all the time. Here's what we know so far about who will end up where in 2022

IndyCar
Sep 15, 2021
Why IndyCar's generational shift isn't as stark as it appears Plus

Why IndyCar's generational shift isn't as stark as it appears

OPINION: The rise of two drivers racing only their second full-season IndyCar campaigns to head the points with four races to go has led to some observers doubting the credentials of the old guard. But they haven't faded away, there's merely a deeper talent pool that is helping to make this season one of the best in recent years

IndyCar
Aug 20, 2021
The F1 champion who became an Indy king in his second career Plus

The F1 champion who became an Indy king in his second career

Emerson Fittipaldi’s decision to go racing with his brother led to him falling out of F1, but he bloomed again on the IndyCar scene. NIGEL ROEBUCK considers a career of two halves

Formula 1
Jul 31, 2021
The lasting legacy of a fallen Indycar rookie Plus

The lasting legacy of a fallen Indycar rookie

Jeff Krosnoff was plucked out of obscurity to become a respected and highly popular professional in Japan, and then got his big break in Indycar for 1996. But a tragic accident at Toronto 25 years ago cut short a promising career and curtailed his regular team-mate Mauro Martini's passion for racing

IndyCar
Jul 14, 2021