Nico Hulkenberg still has 'mixed feelings' on F1 halo after Spa crash

Long-time halo critic Nico Hulkenberg says he still has mixed feelings about the device, despite the role it appears to have played in Charles Leclerc's accident at the Belgian Grand Prix

Hulkenberg has hated the look of the halo since it arrived in Formula 1, but is well aware that many of those who disliked the cockpit protection system have changed their mind since the Spa pile-up, which was triggered when he clattered into Fernando Alonso, sending the McLaren spinning over the top of Leclerc's Sauber and hitting its halo.

But after being asked ahead of the Italian GP whether his own opinion had changed, Hulkenberg says he is still not completely won over.

"I think whilst I am still not a big fan of halo and the device, I have to see the facts and admit that it does bring something to F1, especially the safety we appreciate in the car," he said.

"So divided mixed feelings about it still, but it is not down to me anyway, and it is what it is."

Hulkenberg is clear, however, that the safety credentials of the halo are now beyond doubt.

"It has proven pretty useful and a good device," he said. "We can only speculate on what would have happened without it, but it looks pretty clear from the point the tyre marks were all over the halo.

"So from that point of view it has done a very good job to keep the head safe."

Hulkenberg is not alone in continuing to dislike the look of the halo, with Kevin Magnussen also admitting he does not like it.

"I am just happy that no one got hurt - no one wants to get hurt and no one wants anyone else to get hurt," said the Haas driver. "So that's really the end of the story.

"But it doesn't change the fact that my idea of Formula 1 is without halo, like my idea of motorbike is two wheels.

"But then of course you ask yourself, when you see that the halo just saved a life, you are not going to say, 'oh, I wish it wasn't there'.

"Of course you're happy that it was there in that case."

Leclerc said that the fact he was able to walk away from such a crash - even though it is not proven that Alonso's car would have hit his head - means arguments over the halo's look should now end.

"Looking back at the images, we cannot know what will have happened without it, but obviously I was quite happy to have it over my head," he said.

"And it deserves to be in F1 now. Whether it looks good or bad, I don't think that matters anymore."

shares
comments

Haas says Ferrari will not dictate its 2019 F1 driver line-up

Formula 1's new ballistic-tested helmet revealed at Italian GP

The salvation story behind Benetton's emergence as an F1 team

The salvation story behind Benetton's emergence as an F1 team

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Damien Smith

The salvation story behind Benetton's emergence as an F1 team The salvation story behind Benetton's emergence as an F1 team

Ranking the top 10 Benetton F1 drivers

Ranking the top 10 Benetton F1 drivers

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Damien Smith

Ranking the top 10 Benetton F1 drivers Ranking the top 10 Benetton F1 drivers

When Mansell and Senna settled their differences in an F1 pitlane scuffle

When Mansell and Senna settled their differences in an F1 pitlane scuffle

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Belgian GP
GP Racing

When Mansell and Senna settled their differences in an F1 pitlane scuffle When Mansell and Senna settled their differences in an F1 pitlane scuffle

The F1 treasure map where Hamilton hopes Mercedes hits gold

The F1 treasure map where Hamilton hopes Mercedes hits gold

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Japanese GP
Jonathan Noble

The F1 treasure map where Hamilton hopes Mercedes hits gold The F1 treasure map where Hamilton hopes Mercedes hits gold

The two F1 rules problems Perez’s recent mishaps expose

The two F1 rules problems Perez’s recent mishaps expose

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Japanese GP
Alex Kalinauckas

The two F1 rules problems Perez’s recent mishaps expose The two F1 rules problems Perez’s recent mishaps expose

How football has posed difficult questions for F1

How football has posed difficult questions for F1

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
GP Racing

How football has posed difficult questions for F1 How football has posed difficult questions for F1

The fans that offer a ray of light in an increasingly partisan F1

The fans that offer a ray of light in an increasingly partisan F1

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Japanese GP
Jake Boxall-Legge

The fans that offer a ray of light in an increasingly partisan F1 The fans that offer a ray of light in an increasingly partisan F1

Japanese Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023

Japanese Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Japanese GP
Alex Kalinauckas

Japanese Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023 Japanese Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023

Subscribe