Formula 1 could rethink how it decides driver penalties

Formula 1 could change its approach to penalties so the punishments are more closely aligned with the consequences of drivers' actions

Formula 1 could rethink how it decides driver penalties

Sebastian Vettel's five-second time penalty for the French Grand Prix collision that sent him and Valtteri Bottas to the back of the field last weekend was criticised as inadequate by Lewis Hamilton and Mercedes' non-executive chairman Niki Lauda.

FIA race director Charlie Whitings said stewards are not supposed to consider the consequences for drivers affected by incidents when deciding penalties, only the perpetrators' actions, but hinted this could change.

"The stewards don't normally look at the consequences of the accident," he explained. "Although in fairness it probably plays a little subconscious part.

"Let's just say Vettel had continued without any problem, I think the stewards may have thought 'that's not fair, he's ruined Valtteri's race, it's clearly his fault', and they may have thought slightly differently.

"But it's not a conscious thing to say, 'He's OK, he's not.'

"Or let's say had it been the other way around, let's say Valtteri continued, Vettel had caused the accident, but should you actually penalise him as well as the penalty he's already got? Self-punishment if you like.

"It's something that we're discussing. It could open the door to something that we're not expecting, although some could argue that it's a bit more common sense.

"So it's something that we're currently discussing with the stewards."

The French GP decision also prompted questions over why Max Verstappen's penalty for hitting Vettel in China had been 10s.

Whiting said the difference was that the Shanghai incident happened in the middle of the race.

"I think first-corner incidents, or even first-lap incidents, are looked at through a slightly different pair of eyes," he explained.

"You accept some of the things that happen on the first lap that you might not accept 10 laps later, for obvious reasons."

Whiting also stressed that drivers' past records should not be considered when a penalty is assessed.

"Previous races are not taken into account," he said.

"That's what the [penalty] points system is for. That's a fact. That's one of the cornerstones of the stewards' decision-making process."

The consistency of decision making is now driven by a system called the Race Watch Stewards Review.

Introduced at the start of 2016, it collates all incidents since then with video evidence and detail the outcomes in a single online resource, to which all FIA stewards have access.

This allows them to study details of what happened at races where they did not officiate.

"The stewards can go to any incident and see exactly what the decision was and what the reasons were and what the penalties were," Whiting added. "This is all an attempt to try and make things more consistent."

He said comparison with previous incidents using this system decided the fine McLaren received on Friday for releasing Stoffel Vandoorne into Vettel's path during Austrian GP practice.

shares
comments
Sergio Perez demands Formula 1 kerb consistency after Austria drama

Previous article

Sergio Perez demands Formula 1 kerb consistency after Austria drama

Next article

Austrian Grand Prix: Vettel usurps Mercedes in final practice

Austrian Grand Prix: Vettel usurps Mercedes in final practice
Load comments

About this article

Series Formula 1
Author Adam Cooper
The back-bedroom world-beater that began a new F1 era Plus

The back-bedroom world-beater that began a new F1 era

The first in a line of world beaters was designed in a back bedroom and then constructed in a shed. STUART CODLING recalls the Tyrrell 001

The clues Hamilton’s F1 contract afterthought gives to his future Plus

The clues Hamilton’s F1 contract afterthought gives to his future

The Formula 1 world reacted with surprise when it learned Lewis Hamilton’s long-awaited new Mercedes deal guarantees his presence on the grid only until the end of 2021. Both parties claimed publicly they were happy with the arrangement but, asks MARK GALLAGHER, is there more to it than that?

Formula 1
Apr 17, 2021
How a harshly ejected Red Bull star has been hooked by racing again Plus

How a harshly ejected Red Bull star has been hooked by racing again

Driver-turned-DJ Jaime Alguersuari lost his love for motorsport when he was booted out of Formula 1 just as he was starting to polish his rough edges. Having drifted from category to category then turned his back on racing altogether in 2015, he’s come full circle and is planning a return in karts for fun

Formula 1
Apr 17, 2021
Why Mercedes isn't confident it's really ahead of Red Bull at Imola Plus

Why Mercedes isn't confident it's really ahead of Red Bull at Imola

While Mercedes struck back against Red Bull by topping the times at Imola on Friday ahead of the Emilia Romagna Grand Prix, the overall picture remains incredibly close. Despite having a possible edge this weekend, the reigning Formula 1 world champion squad is not taking anything for granted...

Formula 1
Apr 16, 2021
What Mercedes must do to keep its F1 title challenge on track Plus

What Mercedes must do to keep its F1 title challenge on track

Mercedes may find itself leading the drivers' and constructors' standings after Lewis Hamilton's victory in the Bahrain Grand Prix, but it is well-aware that it came against the odds, with Red Bull clearly ahead on pace. Here's what the Brackley team must do to avoid its crown slipping

Formula 1
Apr 16, 2021
Why Tsunoda can become Japan’s greatest F1 talent Plus

Why Tsunoda can become Japan’s greatest F1 talent

While Japan's fever for motor racing is well-documented, the country has yet to produce a Formula 1 superstar – but that could be about to change, says BEN EDWARDS

Formula 1
Apr 15, 2021
Why the demise of F1's hypocritical spending habit is cause for celebration Plus

Why the demise of F1's hypocritical spending habit is cause for celebration

For too long, F1's richest teams have justified being able to spend as much as they want because that's the way they've always conducted their business. STUART CODLING says that's no reason not to kick a bad habit

Formula 1
Apr 14, 2021
The double whammy that is defining Vettel’s F1 fate Plus

The double whammy that is defining Vettel’s F1 fate

It's been a tough start to Sebastian Vettel's Aston Martin F1 career, with a lack of pre-season testing mileage followed by an incident-packed Bahrain GP. But two key underlying factors mean a turnaround is not guaranteed

Formula 1
Apr 14, 2021