Analysis: F1 Shoots its Foot Again

Formula One has struggled to win over the United States since a Grand Prix in Phoenix 14 years ago sold fewer tickets than an ostrich race across town

Analysis: F1 Shoots its Foot Again

Decimated by the withdrawal of 14 cars due to tyre safety concerns, Sunday's U.S. Grand Prix did nothing to enhance its reputation.

In one stroke, the 'race' wiped out whatever gains had been made over the last few seasons and dealt the supposed glamour sport a major setback in a key market for sponsors and manufacturers.

After talk of expanding to Las Vegas or New York, Formula One's future in the United States looks far less promising. It may not even have one, although Indianapolis has a year to run on its contract.

An estimated crowd of 120,000 people, one of the biggest of the year at a Grand Prix, paid good money to watch a motor race at the Brickyard on Sunday.

What they got was just six cars, four of them the slowest in Formula One, with angry fans hurling beer cans and bottles on the track in frustration.

The fiasco could go down as the worst public relations own-goal yet in a sport that has never been shy of shooting itself in the foot.

Briton David Coulthard, one of the 14 drivers going nowhere after the seven Michelin teams pulled out before the start because of safety concerns about their tyres, summed it up succinctly enough.

"Even if we do come back, half the crowd in the stands today won't be back. That's for sure," the Red Bull driver said.

Minardi boss Paul Stoddart was even more stinging in his criticism.

"If you run something as badly as what we've done today, you wouldn't be surprised if there was never another U.S. Grand Prix," he said.

"Today Formula One lost sight of the word sport."

No Winners

Ferrari's Michael Schumacher crossed the finish line first but, even if team boss Jean Todt likened the result to a technical knockout in boxing, there were no winners.

Michelin messed up, bringing a tyre that could not be used with any guarantee of safety for a race in one of the world's most litigious countries.

As one prominent team member said after the race: "You've got a letter saying the tyres are unsafe, you're in America, what can you do?"

Michelin said they had acted responsibly, in the interests of safety, and once the problem became evident with Ralf Schumacher's crash in Friday practice there was room for a possible compromise.

Nine of the 10 teams wanted a temporary chicane put in before the slingshot final banked corner to reduce speeds and lessen the huge forces on the rear left tyres.

Champions Ferrari and the governing FIA said no.

The governing body offered instead three alternatives: running more slowly through the turn, using a different tyre and picking up a penalty or repeatedly changing a tyre.

Despite several meetings, nobody would compromise and at that point all of Formula One failed.

"Formula One and motor sport fans throughout the World are the losers today. The FIA is now awaiting a report from its observer in Indianapolis before deciding on the next step," said FIA president Max Mosley.

Weak Position

Others saw yet further evidence of the political battle between Mosley and the carmakers, who are threatening their own series from 2008 and are involved with five of the seven teams that did not race on Sunday.

The FIA, which published draft proposals for 2008 regulations last week, has also said it wanted a single tyre supplier in future and Michelin's position will not be strong.

Formula One supremo Bernie Ecclestone looked weaker too, with the sport's ruler failing to broker an agreement that might at least have given the fans the entertainment they paid for.

"This is going to leave a long, lasting bitter taste in people's mouths," Coulthard added.

"Quite frankly, as a driver, I'm embarrassed to be involved in this situation.

"The fact is that mature adults were not able to put on a show for everybody. It's a very sad day for racing."

Karthikeyan: Points are Points

Previous article

Karthikeyan: Points are Points

Next article

Michelin Still Committed to F1

Michelin Still Committed to F1
Load comments

About this article

Series Formula 1
Author Alan Baldwin
The double whammy that is defining Vettel’s F1 fate Plus

The double whammy that is defining Vettel’s F1 fate

It's been a tough start to Sebastian Vettel's Aston Martin F1 career, with a lack of pre-season testing mileage followed by an incident-packed Bahrain GP. But two key underlying factors mean a turnaround is no guarantee

The diva that stole a march on F1’s wide-bodied opposition Plus

The diva that stole a march on F1’s wide-bodied opposition

In 2017 new F1 technical regulations were supposed to add drama - and peg Mercedes back. STUART CODLING looks at the car which, while troubled, set the stage for the wide-bodied Formula 1 era

Formula 1
Apr 13, 2021
The themes to watch in F1’s Imola return Plus

The themes to watch in F1’s Imola return

Three weeks is a long time in Formula 1, but in the reshaped start to the 2021 season the teams head to Imola to pick things up after the frenetic Bahrain opener. Here's what to look out for and the developments to follow at the Emilia Romagna Grand Prix

Formula 1
Apr 13, 2021
The 'new' F1 drivers who need to improve at Imola Plus

The 'new' F1 drivers who need to improve at Imola

After a pandemic-hit winter of seat-swapping, F1 kicked off its season with several new faces in town, other drivers adapting to new environments, and one making a much-anticipated comeback. BEN ANDERSON looks at who made the most of their opportunity and who needs to try harder…

Formula 1
Apr 12, 2021
The delay that quashed Aston Martin’s last F1 venture Plus

The delay that quashed Aston Martin’s last F1 venture

Aston Martin’s only previous foray into Formula 1 in the late 1950s was a short-lived and unsuccessful affair. But it could have been so different, says NIGEL ROEBUCK

Formula 1
Apr 10, 2021
Verstappen exclusive: Why lack of car-racing titles won't hurt Red Bull's ace Plus

Verstappen exclusive: Why lack of car-racing titles won't hurt Red Bull's ace

Max Verstappen’s star quality in Formula 1 is clear. Now equipped with a Red Bull car that is, right now, the world title favourite and the experience to support his talent, could 2021 be the Dutchman’s year to topple the dominant force of Lewis Hamilton and Mercedes?

Formula 1
Apr 9, 2021
Are we at peak F1 right now? Plus

Are we at peak F1 right now?

For many, many years Formula 1 has strived to do and to be better on all fronts. With close competition, a growing fanbase, a stable political landscape and rules in place to encourage sustainability, 2021 is on course to provide an unexpected peak

Formula 1
Apr 8, 2021
How crucial marginal calls will decide the Red Bull vs Mercedes battle in F1 2021 Plus

How crucial marginal calls will decide the Red Bull vs Mercedes battle in F1 2021

The longer Red Bull can maintain a performance edge over Mercedes, the better the odds will be in the team’s favour against the defending world champions. But as the Bahrain Grand Prix showed, many more factors will be critical in the outcome of the 2021 Formula 1 World Championship

Formula 1
Apr 7, 2021