Why the FIA must clamp down on Formula E's needless risk

Nelson Piquet Jr has warned the FIA it is risking a serious accident by not clamping down on unsafe releases in Formula E

Why the FIA must clamp down on Formula E's needless risk

An extremely high amount of very good work goes in to maximise motorsport safety these days, so it's surprising the electric single-seater series still executes its mid-race car swaps the way it does.

When 20 drivers head into the pitlane and try to dive into 10 closely-aligned garages and head back out again, at varying intervals, it's a recipe for trouble.

The two Mahindras nearly collided last Sunday in Berlin as Felix Rosenqvist started to accelerate out of the garage just as Nick Heidfeld was pitting.

Rosenqvist stopped - he said he was always aware he may need to brake to let the oncoming car past - but Heidfeld had already opened the lock on his steering and missed his point of entry (and fortunately everything else as well, 2m32s into the below video).

Then, when Heidfeld finally changed cars he was released into Piquet's path, prompting the inaugural FE champion to later tweet: "Nothing against Mahindra, but we will need to see a big accident in the pitlane for the FIA to finally do something about unsafe releases."

A serious accident hasn't happened because of good fortune and good driver awareness. Those are not fool-proof defences.

Racing has a long list of examples that show it's not difficult for stars to align with negative consequences.

Car swaps will remain a part of FE for one more season after this and more thought should go into how they operate or are policed.

As long as they present an opportunity to lose time, teams and drivers will always push the limit.

That's where mistakes come in and why, even in the third season, unsafe releases keep happening.

Whether there is a way to remove the danger from the car swaps themselves I don't know, but it feels like a more effective deterrent is needed.

FIA sanctions have been wide-ranging for an unsafe release, from four-figure fines and five- and 10-second penalties in Berlin to single-second, 20-second and drivethrough penalties at other races.

The FIA stewards judge each incident on its own merit, but this is where the grey area of interpretation comes in. As a means of policing an issue, this is not right.

It's not a deterrent if a precedent exists for a driver only being given a small penalty.

And having ranging sanctions suggests drivers are being punished because of the consequence instead of the crime.

That logic would indicate the FIA would throw the book at a team should an unsafe release trigger a car getting speared into a team member, for example. And rightly so.

But surely it's better to clamp down harder to begin with and minimise the risk of such an incident before it happens?

Otherwise what is a matter of practicing proper standards will remain a needless safety lottery.

shares
comments
Renault e.dams Formula E team denied Scott Speed as Buemi stand-in
Previous article

Renault e.dams Formula E team denied Scott Speed as Buemi stand-in

Next article

Porsche moves closer to future Formula E programme

Porsche moves closer to future Formula E programme
The key factors behind Porsche's strong start to Formula E's new era Plus

The key factors behind Porsche's strong start to Formula E's new era

A low-key Valencia test left some quarters of Porsche's Formula E squad worried, but a 100% winning start for the German manufacturer's powertrain in 2022-23 underlines its early race day advantage. Porsche's key figures explain the strong start in Gen3, and why the work is only just beginning

Formula E
Feb 1, 2023
How Wehrlein's Diriyah double reveals Formula E's form book shake-up Plus

How Wehrlein's Diriyah double reveals Formula E's form book shake-up

After Porsche-powered drivers locked out the top two positions to open Formula E's new Gen3 era in Mexico, the order was reversed in Diriyah. Ex-Formula 1 driver Pascal Wehrlein's factory car headed Jake Dennis's customer Andretti machine in both races under the Riyadh lights in a display that leaves little doubt as to which package currently has the edge

Formula E
Jan 30, 2023
The first impressions of Formula E's brave new era Plus

The first impressions of Formula E's brave new era

OPINION: Formula E kicked off its Gen3 era at Mexico City with keen anticipation - and anxiety - surrounding its new, more powerful cars. Here's how the new machinery got on in its first race, and what could be open to improvement later down the line

Formula E
Jan 17, 2023
How Dennis dominated Formula E's new generation opener Plus

How Dennis dominated Formula E's new generation opener

Formula E’s Gen3 era kicked off with more unpredictability as Andretti’s Jake Dennis recovered from poor pre-season testing to dominate in Mexico. Here's how it played out and what the opener hints at what is to come in the new generation of the electric series

Formula E
Jan 16, 2023
Is this a Formula E 'nearly man's' best chance yet at title glory? Plus

Is this a Formula E 'nearly man's' best chance yet at title glory?

With braking issues scuppering his championship hopes at a crucial moment in the 2021-22 Formula E season, Mitch Evans is more determined than ever heading into this year. He explains how he plans to make it third time lucky after two title near-misses

Formula E
Jan 12, 2023
Can McLaren make a success of its foray into Formula E? Plus

Can McLaren make a success of its foray into Formula E?

McLaren kept a two-time title-winning Formula E team alive after purchasing the Mercedes entry. But with new drivers and a switch to customer status, can it continue to succeed in its new orange era?

Formula E
Jan 11, 2023
10 things we learned from Valencia Formula E testing Plus

10 things we learned from Valencia Formula E testing

The prologue to the 2022/2023 Formula E season has concluded as the series gets set for the new Gen3 era. After almost four days of testing in Valencia this week, Autosport takes a look at the 10 major talking points that will dominate the build-up to the new campaign getting underway in January.

Formula E
Dec 17, 2022
How Jaguar got its teeth into Formula E's Gen3 development race Plus

How Jaguar got its teeth into Formula E's Gen3 development race

With Mercedes gone and DS moving teams, Jaguar has a big opportunity at the start of Formula E's Gen3 era. The technical challenges in understanding the new car have been vast, with senior figures James Barclay and Phil Charles outlining to Autosport the pitfalls along the way

Formula E
Dec 1, 2022