Skip to main content

Sign up for free

  • Get quick access to your favorite articles

  • Manage alerts on breaking news and favorite drivers

  • Make your voice heard with article commenting.

Autosport Plus

Discover premium content
Subscribe

Recommended for you

DS Penske on the pace in Monaco Formula E opener

Formula E
Monaco ePrix I
DS Penske on the pace in Monaco Formula E opener

Watch LIVE: Nurburgring 24 Hours

GT
Watch LIVE: Nurburgring 24 Hours

Formula E Monaco: De Vries ends win drought, Ticktum loses podium due to penalty

Formula E
Monaco ePrix I
Formula E Monaco: De Vries ends win drought, Ticktum loses podium due to penalty

MotoGP Catalan GP: Marquez beats Acosta to sprint win as Martin crashes

MotoGP
Catalan GP
MotoGP Catalan GP: Marquez beats Acosta to sprint win as Martin crashes

Banking on success: Inside Madrid’s new grand prix circuit

Feature
Formula 1
Spanish GP
Banking on success: Inside Madrid’s new grand prix circuit

Tech3 sticks with KTM for MotoGP's 850cc era after Honda talks

MotoGP
Catalan GP
Tech3 sticks with KTM for MotoGP's 850cc era after Honda talks

MotoGP Catalan GP: Acosta claims pole as Bezzecchi and Martin crash in qualifying

MotoGP
Catalan GP
MotoGP Catalan GP: Acosta claims pole as Bezzecchi and Martin crash in qualifying

After Honda's first annual loss in 70 years, what does it mean for its F1 project?

Formula 1
Canadian GP
After Honda's first annual loss in 70 years, what does it mean for its F1 project?

Why taking over five hours to confirm Russell's Canadian GP win is bad for F1

OPINION: The FIA has worked hard on improving its officiating in races, but the delay in deciding the outcome of the Canadian Grand Prix was a step backwards for F1

George Russell, Mercedes

George Russell, Mercedes

Photo by: James Sutton / Motorsport Images via Getty Images

For a championship that’s measured in nanoseconds, five hours and thirty minutes is an eternity.

Incredibly, in a world of high-definition video cameras integrated into car parts, real-time sensors, GPS trackers, AI technology, and the sophisticated FIA Remote Operations Centre (ROC) in Geneva, it still took that long after the chequered flag to confirm that George Russell had won the Formula 1 Canadian Grand Prix.

By the time the verdict was delivered, the FIA motorhome was desolate, and the organisation’s staff had left the circuit. Perhaps it was fortunate that Red Bull’s protest - alleging Russell drove erratically behind the safety car - was not upheld, as there was nobody left to answer further questions.

The decision stood. The official documents could be printed. The matter was closed.

But the delay was, frankly, embarrassing for F1. It comes at a time when the series is actively trying to grow its audience, particularly in North America - a push boosted by the high-profile film set to premiere on Monday evening in New York.

Granted, the protest process, such as the one launched by Red Bull, is inherently convoluted. But the hearing itself, where Red Bull and Mercedes representatives presented their cases, took just 45 minutes. From there, the rest should have been straightforward.

Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing, George Russell, Mercedes

Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing, George Russell, Mercedes

Photo by: James Sutton / Motorsport Images via Getty Images

Given the tools at its disposal, one would think the FIA could swiftly determine whether Russell did indeed brake “unnecessarily and erratically behind the safety car”, or whether he was guilty of “unsportsmanlike conduct” for reporting Max Verstappen had overtaken him under those conditions.

Ultimately, the stewards concluded that Russell “did not drive erratically by braking where he did or to the extent he did”, and that his report of Verstappen’s accidental overtake did not constitute misconduct.

So, why did it take so long to publish such a clear-cut conclusion?

Part of the problem lies in the process: the stewards investigate incidents in the order they’re reported, not in order of importance. While the stewards investigated other, less significant safety car infringements, the race’s most consequential ruling remained in limbo.

Meanwhile, fans had long since headed home. Broadcasts had ended. For newer viewers especially, how would it feel to learn that the race winner wasn’t officially confirmed until hours later?

George Russell, Mercedes, Andrea Kimi Antonelli, Mercedes

George Russell, Mercedes, Andrea Kimi Antonelli, Mercedes

Photo by: James Sutton / Motorsport Images via Getty Images

There’s no question that F1 is complex and nuanced. Technical protests that require deep investigation understandably take time. But this particular issue seemed binary - something that could be quickly resolved with replays and telemetry.

To the FIA’s credit, it has made strides in improving transparency and communications, and that effort is commendable.

But it remains baffling that in a series defined by speed, governance decisions can be so painfully slow.

Read Also:
Previous article Hamilton's F1 Canadian GP ruined by "devastating" crash with groundhog
Next article How Russell absorbed Verstappen pressure – on- and off-track – to rise in the True North

Top Comments

Latest news