Why F1's competitive order has been mixed up at the Singapore GP

It was a big shock to see the Mercedes Formula 1 team struggle so badly in qualifying for the Singapore Grand Prix

Why F1's competitive order has been mixed up at the Singapore GP

Fifth-placed Lewis Hamilton was over half a second slower than the next fastest car (Daniil Kvyat's Red Bull), and well over a second away from Sebastian Vettel's pole lap.

We're used to seeing Mercedes top sessions by those margins, not be on the receiving end.

The drivers expressed no real dissatisfaction with the handling of the W06 after the session.

From trackside, the car looked well-balanced in final free practice, and Hamilton said afterwards that he had "100 per cent confidence in the car".

Mercedes has "no explanation" for pace

The problem was not one of balance, but simply a lack of overall grip.

So what went wrong?

The problem likely has it roots in a combination of the track layout, the characteristics of Pirelli's super-soft tyre, and how Mercedes has made use of that tyre in Singapore.

Mercedes boss Toto Wolff referenced this in his post-session media briefing, when he described the Marina Bay circuit as a "very special track" and talked of searching for "the sweet spot of the tyre".


Engineers within the paddock say Pirelli's super-soft is what's known as a 'low working range' tyre, which broadly means it's easy to overheat.

But the super-soft is also a compound that Williams performance chief Rob Smedley describes as "very peaky", which means the range of working temperatures to which it will respond is very narrow.

"It's on a knife-edge," he said. "And if you get it dead right then it rewards greatly, and if you don't get it spot on then it can be more than the usual few tenths that you're off the pace."

More commonly you may expect the problem with this tyre to be one of over-working it, causing a fragile compound to lose performance rapidly over the course of a lap.

This seems to be what happened to Romain Grosjean on his Q3 run, when he got wheelspin at Turn 6.

As soon as that happened, he got further wheelspin at Turns 7 and 8 as the rear tyres ran away with overheating, dropping over the hot side of the peak temperature range and costing him rear grip.

Vettel thought Mercedes was sandbagging

You also get some drivers struggling to get the front and rear tyres balanced.

Sometimes the front tyres are not hot enough for the first part of a flying lap, so drivers lock their brakes and lose time through the first sequence of turns, while in the meantime the rear tyres get worked too hard and start to lose performance towards the end of the lap.

This is what happened to Sauber driver Felipe Nasr, who failed to escape Q1 in the updated C34. The car is still weak over the bumps and struggles for traction, which means the surface of the rear tyres can easily overheat and cause an imbalance.

According to Smedley, there is "no single factor" that dictates correct tyre preparation for a particular car, or how that car/driver combination extracts maximum grip from the rubber.

"It's based on a number of factors," he added. "The preparation before the tyres leave the garage, how much energy your car puts into the tyre around the lap, sliding energy, sliding velocities around the lap - and therefore the range of temperatures the tyre sees, not just the single average temperature.

"[Also] whether you can keep it keyed into a small temperature range, or whether because you've got more sliding you're tending to go both sides of the peak."


The layout of Singapore's Marina Bay circuit could also play into explaining why Mercedes struggled here relative to its opposition.

Red Bull and Ferrari were both much closer to Mercedes here than at any other track on the calendar during the 2014 campaign.

The layout places a premium on good braking, strong traction, and skilful driving, while the influence of engine power is greatly reduced, as is the effect of downforce variation between the cars, because most of the corners are of short duration and low speed.

That means Mercedes' usual strengths - high-speed corners and long straights that require efficient recovered energy deployment - are not so evident here.

Of course, Mercedes was very fast in Monaco, where the track is similar in terms of demands, and the same tyre compounds are used, but Singapore is much hotter than Monaco, and the circuit is also much longer, which places far more of a premium on tyre management.

So how quick anyone can be here is about how well the drivers and cars can work and manage the tyre, which is a very complicated and tricky process to get right in this era of high-degradation Pirelli rubber.

It's something Red Bull and latterly Ferrari have been extremely good at in the past, and it has not been one of Mercedes' traditional strengths.

Tough weekend good for Mercedes - Button

The differences could be exacerbated by the length and layout of the track, according to Smedley.

"The tyre is constantly working here, but there are no high-speed corners, so you're not imparting a huge amount of energy into the tyre," he explained.

"We have quite a high value of sliding velocity, so the way the tyre scrubs across the surface of the track.

"You get quite a different relationship here between the bulk temperature and the tyre surface, and it's knowing the key to both of them and how to target both of them.

"There's also not a lot of recovery for the tyre around the lap, so once you put it into a certain situation, trying to recover from that is very difficult.

"On a normal circuit you have a kilometre of straight to recover and it doesn't really remember what it's done a kilometre ago. Here you never stop using it."

This is why Grosjean couldn't recover after his Q3 wheelspin.

The vagaries of the rubber, and the relationship between surface temperature and bulk temperature is something that also confounded McLaren's Jenson Button, who wound up nearly seven tenths adrift of team-mate Fernando Alonso in Q2.

"My second run in qualifying I always picked up massive understeer," he explained.

"We think it's because the brakes get hot. Normally you use the brakes to warm the bulk tyre temperature, and you don't want to raise the surface [temperature] too much.

"I think I was putting too much temperature into the fronts, so always on my second run I had massive understeer even though we put a lot of front wing in.

"I struggled with the tyres today, I'm sure a few others did. I just could not read them at all."

The Mercedes drivers complained of a lack of grip generally, and the early suggestion from within the team is that the W06s were operating the tyre below the correct working range.

Thus the car was well balanced, but just not 'switching on' the tyre enough to go fast.

Why exactly Mercedes could not get the super-soft tyre up into the correct range is still unclear.

"To do that you need to have all the matrices right," explained Wolff. "Rideheight, camber, torque, pressure, temperatures. There is so much influence. This is a new one for us."

The driver also plays a large part in this process, in terms of how they drive their out-laps and 'prepare' the tyres for a quick run.

Small variations in this process between drivers in the same car could explain why Grosjean made Q3 while Pastor Maldonado - complaining of a general lack of grip - could only qualify 18th, or why poleman Vettel was nearly eight tenths faster than Ferrari team-mate Kimi Raikkonen at the end of Q3.

There wasn't ultimately a huge gap between Rosberg and Hamilton (0.115s), so there's unlikely to be a huge variation between the two drivers in the way they managed the tyres.

It's thus more likely to be something related to the set-up of the car.

The team's only hope now the cars are in parc ferme is that things will turn around when every car on the grid is fat with fuel and running on used rubber.

Regardless, F1's usually dominant force faces an uphill struggle to win the Singapore GP from here.

Tough Singapore GP good for Mercedes and F1, says Jenson Button

Previous article

Tough Singapore GP good for Mercedes and F1, says Jenson Button

Next article

How teams are chasing more downforce

How teams are chasing more downforce
Load comments
The other notable Monza escape that F1 should learn from Plus

The other notable Monza escape that F1 should learn from

OPINION: The headlines were dominated by the Italian Grand Prix crash between Max Verstappen and Lewis Hamilton, who had the halo to thank for avoiding potentially serious injury. But two days earlier, Formula 1 had a lucky escape with a Monza pitlane incident that could also have had grave consequences

How Monza only added more questions to F1's sprint race conundrum Plus

How Monza only added more questions to F1's sprint race conundrum

With two sprint races under its belt, Formula 1 must now consider its options for them going forward. While they've helped deliver exciting racing on Sundays, the sprints themselves have been somewhat lacking - creating yet another conundrum for F1 to solve...

Formula 1
Sep 16, 2021
Who should Alfa Romeo sign for 2022's F1 season? Plus

Who should Alfa Romeo sign for 2022's F1 season?

OPINION: With Valtteri Bottas already signed up for 2022, all eyes are on the race for the second seat at Alfa Romeo next year. Antonio Giovinazzi is the current incumbent, but faces a tough competition from appealing short and long-term prospects

Formula 1
Sep 15, 2021
The "forced break" that was key to Ricciardo's Monza excellence Plus

The "forced break" that was key to Ricciardo's Monza excellence

OPINION: Daniel Ricciardo has long been considered one of Formula 1’s elite drivers. But his struggles at McLaren since switching from Renault for 2021 have been painful to watch at times. Yet he’s recovered to banish those memories with a famous Monza win – built on a critically important foundation

Formula 1
Sep 14, 2021
How Verstappen is ruining his F1 title battle with Hamilton Plus

How Verstappen is ruining his F1 title battle with Hamilton

OPINION: The Italian GP clash between Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen followed a running theme in the 2021 Formula 1 title fight. Their close-quarters battles have often resulted in contact - and although Hamilton has shown a willingness to back off, Verstappen must learn to temper his aggression

Formula 1
Sep 14, 2021
Italian Grand Prix Driver Ratings Plus

Italian Grand Prix Driver Ratings

Two drivers produced maximum-score performances as, for the second year in a row, Monza threw up an unpredictable result that left several others ruing what might have been

Formula 1
Sep 13, 2021
Why Ricciardo was set for Monza F1 triumph even without Verstappen/Hamilton crash Plus

Why Ricciardo was set for Monza F1 triumph even without Verstappen/Hamilton crash

The clash between Max Verstappen and Lewis Hamilton was the major flashpoint the 2021 Italian Grand Prix will be remembered for. Yet by this point, race leader Daniel Ricciardo had already done the hard work that would put him in position to end his and McLaren's lengthy win droughts, on a memorable afternoon in Monza

Formula 1
Sep 13, 2021
Why Italian GP success is on for McLaren even if Verstappen dominates Plus

Why Italian GP success is on for McLaren even if Verstappen dominates

For the second time in 2021, McLaren will line up for the start of a grand prix from the first row. It knows it has the chance of “glory” if things go well for Daniel Ricciardo and Lando Norris at the start of the 2021 Italian Grand Prix, but even if they just maintain their grid positions, signs from the rest of the Monza weekend suggest success is very possible for Formula 1’s other orange army

Formula 1
Sep 12, 2021