Mosley Slams BAR Reasons to Drop Case

FIA President Max Mosley has ridiculed BAR Honda's claim that they did not pursue an appeal against the team's two-race ban in the civil courts because of issues of jurisdiction, with Mosley suggesting it was the fear of being embarassed that stopped them from taking matters further

"They know that the whole thing would be out in the open and their case would collapse," Mosley said in Barcelona. "We'd have someone cross-examining their witnesses and it would be somewhere between an embarrassment and a disaster."

Mosley defended the FIA stewards at Imola, saying that they were working under pressure and, in the time frame available, were unwilling to throw BAR Honda out.

"As judges of first instance sometimes do, they did not interpret the regulations properly," Mosley claimed. "They allowed themselves to be convinced with all sorts of data that the car had not gone under 600kgs.

"But there were two problems with that. One, the teams can't prove that just by using data, that's what Article 2.6 says - you have to do it by physical inspection.

"The second problem was that the data assumed that the rate of fuel consumption was constant, and there's no means of knowing that. So, for all anyone knew, it could have gone under 600kgs but, anyway, whether it did or not is irrelevant because the actual car weighed less than 600kgs.

"The stewards got it wrong, it's that simple, and that's why we appealed."

Mosley says that it was such an open and shut case that the FIA did not bother to send a barrister to the FIA Court of Appeal.

"Once you analyse it clearly there is no debate," he said. "The BAR team had one of the cleverest people in the English legal system (David Pannick). He's brilliant. He acted for us against BAR when we had that arbitration (concerning the running of team cars in dual livery). That's how they found out about him!

"I think another time I'd send a barrister who's a good cross-examiner because what was needed was a good cross-examination of their weaknesses and then their whole case would have dissolved into tatters."

 

shares
comments

Fisichella Fastest in Practice 3 - Spain

Ralf Fastest in Practice 4 - Spain

Why precedent doesn’t favour Massa’s F1 legal challenge

Why precedent doesn’t favour Massa’s F1 legal challenge

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
GP Racing

Why precedent doesn’t favour Massa’s F1 legal challenge Why precedent doesn’t favour Massa’s F1 legal challenge

Why Sainz’s Singapore F1 success was not just about DRS genius

Why Sainz’s Singapore F1 success was not just about DRS genius

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Singapore GP
Jonathan Noble

Why Sainz’s Singapore F1 success was not just about DRS genius Why Sainz’s Singapore F1 success was not just about DRS genius

 The signs that suggest an immediate Red Bull resurgence in F1's Japanese GP

The signs that suggest an immediate Red Bull resurgence in F1's Japanese GP

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Japanese GP
Alex Kalinauckas

The signs that suggest an immediate Red Bull resurgence in F1's Japanese GP The signs that suggest an immediate Red Bull resurgence in F1's Japanese GP

The lessons Russell can take from his "two-centimetre" Singapore F1 mistake

The lessons Russell can take from his "two-centimetre" Singapore F1 mistake

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Singapore GP
Jake Boxall-Legge

The lessons Russell can take from his "two-centimetre" Singapore F1 mistake The lessons Russell can take from his "two-centimetre" Singapore F1 mistake

Singapore Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023

Singapore Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Singapore GP
Alex Kalinauckas

Singapore Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023 Singapore Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2023

The Singapore secrets that helped Sainz end Verstappen's F1 winning streak

The Singapore secrets that helped Sainz end Verstappen's F1 winning streak

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
Singapore GP
Jake Boxall-Legge

The Singapore secrets that helped Sainz end Verstappen's F1 winning streak The Singapore secrets that helped Sainz end Verstappen's F1 winning streak

How a McLaren winner overshadowed by scandal was dealt self-inflicted setbacks

How a McLaren winner overshadowed by scandal was dealt self-inflicted setbacks

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
GP Racing

How a McLaren winner overshadowed by scandal was dealt self-inflicted setbacks How a McLaren winner overshadowed by scandal was dealt self-inflicted setbacks

The numbers that reveal F1's aerodynamic efficiency improvements

The numbers that reveal F1's aerodynamic efficiency improvements

Plus
Plus
Formula 1
GP Racing

The numbers that reveal F1's aerodynamic efficiency improvements The numbers that reveal F1's aerodynamic efficiency improvements

Subscribe