Find out more about our subscriptions

Hamilton, Ryan refused to change story

Lewis HamiltonLewis Hamilton and McLaren's former sporting director Dave Ryan refused to change their story about having deliberately let Jarno Trulli through at the Australian Grand Prix, despite being played radio conversations and media interviews that suggested the contrary in their second stewards' hearing at Sepang.

This week's AUTOSPORT reveals that Hamilton and Ryan maintained their stance in that second hearing that Trulli had taken it upon himself to overtake the McLaren in the closing stages of the Melbourne race, even though the stewards presented them with fresh evidence to say they were lying.

In the first detailed account of the stewards' hearings that have resulted in McLaren being called before the FIA's World Motor Sport Council, AUTOSPORT reports that Ryan and Hamilton stuck to their original story when recalled for the second hearing.

An FIA source told AUTOSPORT: "First of all, Lewis heard the radio exchange. It appeared that the strategy was to be extremely vague and not be very direct with the answers. Then the interview where he said, 'I was told to let him through' was played.

"At that point they both got very uncomfortable, but still denied that's what had actually happened.

"It was a bit surreal, this situation where you had the radio evidence and the interview, and they were putting a completely different interpretation on what the words actually meant. But the words were very, very clear."

FIA race director Charlie Whiting has also revealed that Hamilton denied more than once in the original hearing in Australia that he had let Trulli pass him.

Whiting said: "When asked very clearly, 'Did you consciously let him past, did you pull over to let him past', he [Hamilton] said, 'No'. The question was asked more than once. He was adamant that he hadn't slowed down and hadn't let Trulli past."

This week's AUTOSPORT contains a full analysis of what happened on track and in the stewards' room in the controversy, as well as a look at what the situation means for McLaren's future.

  More news  
Read the AUTOSPORT Digital Edition
Visit the shop
See highlights from 60 years of AUTOSPORT
Paddock insight from group F1 editor Jonathan Noble
Grand Prix news updates from F1 editor Edd Straw
Breaking news feed
Live commentary feed
Hamilton 'nearly quit' over '09 scandal
Alonso: Hamilton will restore reputation
The FIA's decision on McLaren in full
FIA publishes full McLaren verdict
Mosley: McLaren penalty not lenient
Whitmarsh grateful for FIA treatment
McLaren handed suspended ban
Whitmarsh: FIA relationship improved
Whitmarsh realistic on partners' future
McLaren sends written apology to FIA
Whitmarsh: Hamilton committed to team
Whitmarsh offered to resign
Trulli: FIA right to punish McLaren
FIA requests BBC's Whitmarsh tapes
Hamilton apologised to FIA's Whiting
Ecclestone: McLaren could face ban
McLaren parts company with Ryan
McLaren summoned by FIA's WMSC
Q & A with Martin Whitmarsh
McLaren: Hamilton not looking to leave
Whitmarsh admits to big errors
Hamilton considered quitting over Oz GP
Mosley: No decision on McLaren yet
McLaren could face further sanctions
Alonso: McLaren has lied before
Q & A with Lewis Hamilton
Hamilton apologises for 'huge mistake'
McLaren 'embarrassed' by Oz events
McLaren confirms Ryan's suspension
McLaren could split with sporting director
FIA insists McLaren misled stewards
Transcript of McLaren radio transmission
The full decision by the FIA stewards
Q & A with Martin Whitmarsh
Whitmarsh says McLaren did not lie
McLaren won't appeal Hamilton exclusion
Q & A with Jarno Trulli
Delighted Trulli says he has 'got justice'
Hamilton disqualified from Australian GP
Hamilton, Trulli summoned by FIA
FIA to re-open Hamilton/Trulli inquiry
Toyota withdraws Trulli appeal
FIA still waiting on Toyota appeal
Trulli: No choice but to pass Hamilton
Trulli penalised, Hamilton gets third
Trulli's third place under investigation