Ricciardo wins as Vergne penalised
|By Peter Mills||Sunday, May 15th 2011, 11:49 GMT|
Red Bull Junior drivers Daniel Ricciardo and Jean-Eric Vergne staged an incredible, and ultimately controversial, duel for victory in Monza's second Formula Renault 3.5 race today.
Carlin's Vergne finished ahead on the road, but received a 10-second penalty during the race for cutting two chicanes. ISR driver Ricciardo picked up his first victory of 2011 as a result.
Both men were among a number of drivers to cut the first chicane in a chaotic start. Ricciardo's first corner lapse was more severe and the Australian lifted off to tuck in behind Vergne, who had lost the left flap of his front wing in contact with Saturday's winner Kevin Korjus (Tech 1 Racing).
Vergne drove superbly to maintain the lead in his damaged car until lap 11, when Ricciardo got fully alongside into the Roggia chicane. Running wheel-to-wheel and inches apart in the mid-corner, Vergne elected to cut the final part of the chicane to avoid contact, but in doing maintained his position.
"I think that was one of my best races ever, having [half a front wing] may have been quick on the straight but for sure we were having problems on the brakes," said Vergne. "Having this problem, plus my engineer telling me we had a 10s penalty, and having no idea why, was pretty hard.
"They told me I was penalised for twice cutting the chicane. The first time was not my fault, everyone was locking wheels, I broke my front wing, and there was no other choice. The second time I cut just a little bit the second chicane to avoid any problem with Daniel. I could have taken it but for sure we would have touched and both spun. For sure we will protest this."
Ricciardo's ISR crew informed him of Vergne's penalty and, with Fortec's Alexander Rossi in third not within striking distance, the Toro Rosso reserve driver played it safe to the chequered flag.
"It would have been nice to cross the line in first but we'll take it," said Ricciardo. "I cut quite a lot Turn 1, if I had continued I would have had a very big gap and I thought I would get penalised. So I came off the throttle and put my hand up to make it obvious that I understood what I did was wrong."
"[Then later] I came up alongside [at the Roggia] and I went through and Jean-Eric kept going. I was surprised we didn't touch, it's one of the problems we have with run-off but you could say that I had the inside and maybe Jean-Eric should have given the right of way."
Vergne drops to third, behind Rossi, as a result of the penalty. Rossi's progress was aided by a confused start. Tech 1 Racing's Arthur Pic, starting from sixth, Anton Nebylitskiy and Daniil Move all jumped the start to varying degrees.
At the exit of the chicane, Korjus went off the road owing to a punctured right-rear as consequence of the contact with Vergne.
A fantastic five-car battle for the lead then developed over the early laps, with Vergne leading Ricciardo, Spa winner Robert Wickens (Carlin), Epic Racing's Albert Costa in fourth and Rossi.
Costa gained a great run on Wickens from the exit of the Serraglio on lap eight, but approaching the braking zone for the Ascari chicane the pair made contact. Wickens speared off into the barriers on the outside of the corner, while Costa survived a bumpy excursion across the Ascari's grass run-off to finish fifth behind Cesar Ramos (Fortec).
Pic finished sixth on the road but slipped to ninth when his 10s jump-start penalty is applied. Mofaz Racing's Chris van der Drift inherited the position.
Vergne leads the drivers' standings on 90 points, Rossi is second on 73. Despite Wickens' double retirement this weekend, the Canadian is third on 71. Today's victory promotes Ricciardo to seventh, 54 points adrift of Vergne.
Results - 28 laps: Pos Driver Team Time/Gap 1. Daniel Ricciardo ISR 46m31.962s 2. Alexander Rossi Fortec + 2.565s 3. Jean-Eric Vergne Carlin + 9.492s 4. Cesar Ramos Fortec + 11.161s 5. Albert Costa Epic + 11.508s 6. Chris van der Drift Mofaz + 20.918s 7. Nelson Panciatici KMP + 21.284s 8. Sergio Canamasas BVM Target + 22.129s 9. Arthur Pic Tech 1 + 22.180s 10. Andre Negrao Draco + 24.735s 11. Oliver Webb Pons + 28.644s 12. Jan Charouz Gravity-Charouz + 34.434s 13. Walter Grubmuller P1 + 39.030s 14. Daniel de Jong Comtec + 39.391s 15. Stephane Richelmi Draco + 40.361s 16. Jake Rosenzweig Mofaz + 41.929s 17. Daniel Zampieri BVM Target + 43.292s 18. Filip Salaquarda Pons + 48.199s 19. Anton Nebylitskiy KMP + 51.139s Retirements: Daniel McKenzie Comtec 24 laps Robert Wickens Carlin 7 laps Brendon Hartley Gravity-Charouz 2 laps Sten Pentus Epic 2 laps Kevin Korjus Tech 1 2 laps Nathanael Berthon ISR 0 laps Daniil Move P1 0 laps