Miller: Claims MotoGP title illegitimate without Marquez are "complete crock"

Jack Miller says claims that a MotoGP title win against an injured Marc Marquez would be illegitimate are a "complete crock" as all riders "have the opportunity to get injured"

Miller: Claims MotoGP title illegitimate without Marquez are "complete crock"

Reigning world champion Marquez broke his right arm in a heavy crash in last weekend's Spanish Grand Prix and had been set to miss this weekend's Andalusian GP at Jerez following surgery on Tuesday.

However, he has been declared fit after confirming his intentions to make a sensational return.

In the immediate aftermath of Marquez's incident, Honda team boss Alberto Puig courted controversy when he said a rider benefitting from Marquez's injury to win the title couldn't be "completely satisfied".

PLUS: Why Marquez isn't Vinales' main threat in MotoGP this year

Puig has since insisted his comments were taken out of turn, and said they came from his own experiences of winning the 1995 Spanish GP at Jerez after reigning champion Mick Doohan crashed out.

"Obviously, whoever wins the championship will be the just winner and deserve it," Puig said on Thursday.

"But my opinion, and I know what I am talking about, is that when you win but the champion is not on the track you always have something left inside.

"I will set my example: I won a race here in 1995, and I've always wondered if I would have won it if Mick Doohan hadn't fallen.

"The same would not have happened. That is what I meant. Because the champion, without Marc, will always have that in his head."

When asked about Puig's original quotes, however, Miller felt the opinion was not "valid".

"I've heard two people say now two questions about the validity of the championship, and it's a complete crock," he said.

"We all started on Friday or Wednesday 100% fit. One guy gets injured, doesn't matter.

"We all get injured. I mean they keep bringing it up, that's not valid.

"We all have the opportunity to get injured and it's the risk you take."

Autosport asked the current top three in the standings - Fabio Quartararo, Maverick Vinales and Andrea Dovizioso - for their takes on the claims, but they steered clear.

Dovizioso said: "This championship is a bit different and the rules are the same for everybody.

"We have to try to win in 12 races. Marc, it looks like he will be on track, so nothing changes."

shares
comments
Why Marquez isn't Vinales' main threat in MotoGP this year
Previous article

Why Marquez isn't Vinales' main threat in MotoGP this year

Next article

MotoGP riders split on new yellow flag rule brought in for Andalusian GP

MotoGP riders split on new yellow flag rule brought in for Andalusian GP
The talent-outweighing ambition that will kill Ducati’s 2022 MotoGP title hopes Plus

The talent-outweighing ambition that will kill Ducati’s 2022 MotoGP title hopes

OPINION: For the fourth time in 2022, Francesco Bagnaia has made a costly error while battling other riders. Crashing while chasing one point at the Japanese Grand Prix has lost him eight to a struggling Fabio Quartararo. With just four rounds remaining and a history of errors in high-pressure situations, Bagnaia and Ducati need a serious rethink to stop its best opportunity of a title in 15 years slipping away

MotoGP
Sep 26, 2022
The unique advantage Ducati must now use to win the 2022 MotoGP title Plus

The unique advantage Ducati must now use to win the 2022 MotoGP title

Ducati has littered the grid with eight strong motorcycles that has ensured it has had at least one rider stand on the podium at every grand prix in 2022. The drama of the Aragon Grand Prix has thrust Francesco Bagnaia well and truly into title contention with five races to go, and Ducati must now consider utilising a unique strength it has so far been reticent to embrace

MotoGP
Sep 19, 2022
How KTM failed one of its brightest MotoGP prospects Plus

How KTM failed one of its brightest MotoGP prospects

Reigning Moto2 champion Remy Gardner’s career has been derailed by KTM’s decision not to retain him at Tech3 for 2023. Amid difficult circumstances, Gardner hasn’t shamed himself. But KTM’s apparent reasoning for dropping him raises questions about its handling of its young riders and the unrealistic expectations placed on them

MotoGP
Sep 6, 2022
Why it won’t just be Marquez’s speed that saves Honda in MotoGP Plus

Why it won’t just be Marquez’s speed that saves Honda in MotoGP

OPINION: Honda is in the midst of a second winless season in the space of three years. The absence of the injured Marc Marquez has been a major contributing factor, but HRC’s inability to alter its own approach has seen it slide down the order. Marquez returned to the MotoGP paddock in Austria and provided a rallying cry Honda needed to hear.

MotoGP
Aug 22, 2022
The signs Quartararo’s 2022 MotoGP title is slipping away from him Plus

The signs Quartararo’s 2022 MotoGP title is slipping away from him

Prior to the summer break, the 2022 MotoGP title looked like it was Fabio Quartararo’s to lose. But a crash at Assen and the consequential penalty he had to serve last weekend at Silverstone stopped him from capitalising on a main rival’s injury woes, while a resurgence from another, plus the rise of a former team-mate, look set to conspire against the Yamaha rider

MotoGP
Aug 8, 2022
Why Marquez’s toughest MotoGP foe is stopping at the right time Plus

Why Marquez’s toughest MotoGP foe is stopping at the right time

On the eve of the British Grand Prix, Andrea Dovizioso announced that he will be retiring from MotoGP after September’s San Marino GP. The timing of his departure raised eyebrows, but his reasoning remains sensible and what has happened this year should not diminish a hard-built legacy

MotoGP
Aug 6, 2022
Why a Suzuki refugee feels he deserves MotoGP's toughest challenge Plus

Why a Suzuki refugee feels he deserves MotoGP's toughest challenge

Alex Rins’ MotoGP future was plunged into sudden doubt when Suzuki elected to quit the series at the end of 2022. Securing a deal with Honda to join LCR, he will now tread a path that many have fallen off from. But it was a move he felt his status deserved, and it’s a challenge – he tells Autosport - he faces with his eyes wide open…

MotoGP
Jul 27, 2022
How Formula 1 has driven MotoGP's changing nature Plus

How Formula 1 has driven MotoGP's changing nature

The hiring of technicians from Formula 1 has clearly contributed to a recent change in the MotoGP landscape, with the role of engineers gaining greater significance relative to the riders. Here's how this shift has come about

MotoGP
Jul 19, 2022