Ducati could protest Honda after row over winglet legality in Qatar

Ducati says it may consider lodging a protest against its MotoGP rival Honda as the row over the legality of its controversial rear winglet escalates

Ducati could protest Honda after row over winglet legality in Qatar

Honda was among the four premier-class manufacturers that protested Ducati in the aftermath of the Qatar MotoGP opener, questioning the legality of the 'spoon' appendage that featured just in front of the rear wheel on the three Desmosedici GP19 bikes.

The protest was thrown out by the FIM stewards at the race, but was subsequently referred to the MotoGP Court of Appeals, which is due to rule on the matter before the next race in Argentina.

Ducati tech chief Gigi Dall'Igna says he is most irked by Honda's participation in the protest, rather than Aprilia's, Suzuki's or KTM's.

"I was quite surprised above all by the behaviour of Honda which, in addition to being a protagonist of the world championship, is also one of the founding fathers of modern MotoGP together with Ducati and Yamaha [which didn't protest]," Dall"Igna told Sky Italia.

"I don't have much to say about this in the case of KTM and Aprilia. If I were them right now, I would be thinking of something else and trying to develop the bike a bit.

"The approach that Suzuki and Honda can take is different, because they can actually take a real advantage of a possible disqualification of [Qatar GP winner Andrea] Dovizioso and Ducati from the first race of the championship."


Ducati believes the legality of the appendage was covered by a note from MotoGP technical director Danny Aldridge ahead of Qatar, although Aprilia, which was the driving force between the protest, has claimed that Aldridge had previously told it a similar part would be ruled illegal.

"Until now, all disputes of a technical nature had been resolved either within the Manufacturers' Association or by discussing them with the technical director," Dall'Igna continued.

"The fact that Honda has questioned the choices of the technical director puts us in a position to raise the question of whether to make a complaint against them.

"Honda's wings are honestly dangerous for us. Not only that, but as they are made with such a slender base, they could be subject to significant deformation from the loads they are subjected to, and therefore could perhaps perform the function of movable aerodynamic devices [which are forbidden].

"We had never considered a complaint in this respect, but if anyone, particularly Honda, has questioned the work of Danny Aldridge, we could evaluate a possible complaint in future races."

The debate over Ducati's device hinges on whether or not its primary purpose is to cool the rear tyre, as the manufacturer claims, rather than generate downforce.

"We are absolutely calm, because our device is used to cool the rear rubber and we have evidence to prove it," Dall'Igna said.

"We have so much evidence that justifies our behavior, that we are not worried at all."

Ducati sporting director Paolo Ciabatti has previously suggested that the protest was "political" in nature.

"I think they wanted to intimidate us and prevent us from using a part that had already been approved by the technical director," said Dall'Igna.

"Obviously we decided to use this and then they found themselves forced to continue in a situation that, if I were in their shoes, I would find embarrassing."

shares
comments
Dorna: MotoE 2019 season will go ahead despite cancelled opener
Previous article

Dorna: MotoE 2019 season will go ahead despite cancelled opener

Next article

MotoE reveals cause of fire that destroyed all its bikes at Jerez

MotoE reveals cause of fire that destroyed all its bikes at Jerez
Was the MotoGP 2022 title won by Bagnaia or lost by Quartararo? Plus

Was the MotoGP 2022 title won by Bagnaia or lost by Quartararo?

Reigning MotoGP world champion Fabio Quartararo had a 91-point lead over rival Francesco Bagnaia after the German Grand Prix, a seemingly impregnable gap to overcome in the remaining 10 races. But as the Frenchman struggled for pace with his Yamaha, Bagnaia stormed back into contention and swept to Ducati's first riders' title since 2007

MotoGP
Nov 25, 2022
Why there's more to Honda's 2023 MotoGP bike than the Valencia test suggests Plus

Why there's more to Honda's 2023 MotoGP bike than the Valencia test suggests

After a run on Honda's 2023 prototype MotoGP bike, six-time champion Marc Marquez made his pessimism clear with his initial reaction. But the Japanese marque has made leadership changes behind closed doors - and a more representative bike promised for the Malaysia test in February could placate Marquez

MotoGP
Nov 23, 2022
Why the new MotoGP world champion has a stronger character than it seems Plus

Why the new MotoGP world champion has a stronger character than it seems

While new MotoGP champion Francesco Bagnaia might not be the loudest rider on the grid, his calm exterior belies a steely backbone. His part in turning around Ducati's fortunes at the start of the year, when displeased with a new engine concept, shows the strength of his character

MotoGP
Nov 16, 2022
Why Bagnaia's MotoGP triumph is as worthy as Stoner's Ducati breakthrough Plus

Why Bagnaia's MotoGP triumph is as worthy as Stoner's Ducati breakthrough

OPINION: Despite the superiority exhibited by the Ducati in 2022, the context in which Francesco Bagnaia became MotoGP world champion means that both the rider and the Italian marque merit the same recognition that the brand and Casey Stoner received after their 2007 title

MotoGP
Nov 9, 2022
Why the 2022 MotoGP season had a bittersweet ending Plus

Why the 2022 MotoGP season had a bittersweet ending

OPINION: MotoGP’s fifth last round showdown of the modern era delivered a tense finale despite the predictable outcome, as Francesco Bagnaia ended 15 years of pain for Ducati. But as emotions ran high for the Italian marque, a final victory for a departing Japanese rival tinged the campaign’s conclusion with sadness

MotoGP
Nov 7, 2022
Why the 2023 MotoGP title battle has already begun Plus

Why the 2023 MotoGP title battle has already begun

Since Ducati announced the arrival of Enea Bastianini to its factory team for 2023, the staging of the four-time race winner has strained the atmosphere within the Italian manufacturer, which has raised its guard in anticipation of what may happen between him and championship favourite Francesco Bagnaia

MotoGP
Nov 1, 2022
Why Yamaha has just six months to safeguard its MotoGP champion's future Plus

Why Yamaha has just six months to safeguard its MotoGP champion's future

Yamaha's decision to dispense pre-season with the 2022 engine it had intended to use due to lack of reliability, the promises of improvement to Fabio Quartararo and the advance with which the rider market moves leaves the Japanese brand with less than six months to prevent the Frenchman from starting to look for a way out

MotoGP
Oct 28, 2022
The war brewing as Ducati nears its ultimate MotoGP prize Plus

The war brewing as Ducati nears its ultimate MotoGP prize

OPINION: Francesco Bagnaia has put one hand firmly on the 2022 MotoGP world title after winning the Malaysian Grand Prix, and the permutations are weighted heavily in his favour heading to the Valencia finale. But as Ducati stands on the cusp of something it has longed for since 2007, the Sepang race also hinted towards a future problem…

MotoGP
Oct 25, 2022