Engineering
Topic

Engineering

Why the time is right for an electric junior series

OPINION: Formula E’s ambitious plans to create a ladder of electric support series faces challenges, but the Audi FE stalwart believes these can be overcome as long as cost is at the forefront of the conversation

Why the time is right for an electric junior series

Alberto Longo has outlined his plan to have a “full ladder” of electric support series to Formula E, including a junior championship. But is this a viable idea that the market needs, and could it thrive against the well-defined Formula 1 support platforms: FIA Formula 3 and Formula 2?

The most important consideration for any junior series is cost, but electrification doesn’t have to mean that it will be more expensive than combustion. Consider the cost per horsepower produced by an Audi e-Tron GT with commercial motors, and it is fairly cost-effective.

It’s also much easier to accurately control the power output of an electric motor using software than for a combustion engine. Large production-scale motors are even closer in performance than high-precision combustion motors, so it’s more precise and cheaper to equalise the equipment for everybody. This would be a huge advantage for an electric junior series seeking to prepare drivers, as combustion engines are rarely ever the same.

This is an issue all the way up the ladder from go-karts, where you need 10 or more engines if you want to be competitive. That’s where the costs lie – the equipment you must have and how much maintenance they need. From F3 to GP2, there would be a 1% margin – up or down – on engine power. If your engine was performing in the bottom 1%, then already you were starting three or four tenths down. It’s also very expensive to get everything equalised, but this issue is removed with electric propulsion. It also needs less maintenance.

Formula E’s traditional inner-city street circuits would be another potential obstacle for a junior series, because one of the main criteria it would need to offer drivers is mileage. The tracks can be extremely costly because the proximity of the walls means you cannot afford a mistake. If you have a young driver who is crashing all the time and doesn’t get the mileage necessary, the cost per mile then becomes very expensive.

Street circuits punish mistakes harder than conventional tracks, so a blend of the two could make for a more cost-effective solution for young drivers

Street circuits punish mistakes harder than conventional tracks, so a blend of the two could make for a more cost-effective solution for young drivers

Photo by: Sam Bloxham / Motorsport Images

The logistics costs involved with racing in cities are also very high and you would need a different race format to allow for shorter races, because a high-capacity battery would also add extra cost. In order to be feasible therefore, any electric junior series would need to race at a combination of key Formula E venues with permanent tracks on different configurations.

If all this is done in a smart way that makes the overall operating costs lower, then we can be close to a break-even point. I believe we could soon arrive to an equivalency of costs compared to existing F1 support series, and in the future I expect it will only get cheaper to do something close to what Formula E will be, with four-wheel drive and re-gen. If an electric junior series is cheaper as a category to arrive to Formula E than F3 or F2, then maybe a racing driver who just wants to become a professional rather than go to F1 could follow this route.

Naturally, every aspiring racing driver dreams of F1, but this is only feasible for a select few. Sometimes even being the best driver in your year isn’t good enough, which is a hard lesson to learn when you’ve already spent €6million and then have to learn all the skills needed in Formula E anyway.

It’s not about an electric junior series offering more or less development opportunities to drivers than F2 or F3 as they would involve developing very different skills. If cost is not a factor, then it becomes a question over what package drivers want to do. There will always be drivers who want to go for F1 but, if a cost-effective electric pathway can be created, it would prepare drivers with the right skills not only for Formula E, but also for Electric GT, Pure ETCR and other series that will follow.

As motorsport progresses to electric more and more, a junior series looking at electrification will become more affordable for drivers and more appealing for sponsors, so naturally the market will shift towards it. I think it’s a good idea for Formula E to pursue and, although there are many challenges, especially for logistics and battery costs, the timing is right to start.

Lucas di Grassi, Audi Sport ABT Schaeffler, Audi e-tron FE07

Lucas di Grassi, Audi Sport ABT Schaeffler, Audi e-tron FE07

Photo by: Simon Galloway / Motorsport Images

shares
comments
W Series driver Powell joins Envision Virgin as Formula E sim driver

Previous article

W Series driver Powell joins Envision Virgin as Formula E sim driver

Next article

Jaguar Land Rover formally commits to Gen3 Formula E rules

Jaguar Land Rover formally commits to Gen3 Formula E rules
Load comments
Why Audi was right and wrong in Formula E's loophole row Plus

Why Audi was right and wrong in Formula E's loophole row

OPINION: With Audi's Formula E exit imminent, it had nothing to lose in London by attempting to vault Lucas di Grassi into the lead by pitting him under the safety car. Scorn directed at the team for putting glory before ethics should instead be pointed at a rulebook that allowed such a move in the first place

Formula E
Jul 27, 2021
Why Formula E's London return delivered anarchy in the UK Plus

Why Formula E's London return delivered anarchy in the UK

Formula E landed for a London E-Prix for the first time since 2016, at the indoor-outdoor circuit around the ExCeL. Featuring the birth of renewed title pushes, a long-awaited maiden win and the second race's controversy, the round proved to be an exhibition of the electric series' anarchic nature

Formula E
Jul 26, 2021
Why consistency can't be relied upon for Formula E title success Plus

Why consistency can't be relied upon for Formula E title success

It's commonly upheld as the most straightforward method of racking up titles. But, due to the unique qualifying format used in Formula E, a consistent approach can actively work against a driver and make their life harder in races. So with four races to go, is now the time to ditch the tried-and-tested approach for a win-or-bust mentality?

Formula E
Jul 23, 2021
How Bird's crash recovery became Formula E's fairytale of New York Plus

How Bird's crash recovery became Formula E's fairytale of New York

After crashing in practice during the opening session at the New York City E-Prix, Sam Bird immediately had a recovery job on his hands. But the Jaguar driver rose through the order and secured victory in the second race - and with it, the championship lead. Here's how an Englishman in New York became top of the heap

Formula E
Jul 12, 2021
Why Formula E is plotting a major change of philosophy Plus

Why Formula E is plotting a major change of philosophy

Formula E has become famed for its unpredictability, which can yield exciting races - but it can be argued that it robs the all-electric championship of a clear narrative and doesn't adequately reward the best drivers. The series wants to change that, and renew its philosophy ahead of the introduction of its next-generation car

Formula E
Jun 29, 2021
How Puebla's high-altitude encounter gave Formula E's new leader breathing space Plus

How Puebla's high-altitude encounter gave Formula E's new leader breathing space

With the usual Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez venue unavailable to Formula E, it visited the little Puebla circuit to keep its foot in the door in Mexico. A near-winner two years ago, Pascal Wehrlein looked in swaggering form throughout the weekend - but a breathless final encounter helped put Edoardo Mortara in the driving seat

Formula E
Jun 21, 2021
The half-term report cards of each Formula E team in 2020-21 Plus

The half-term report cards of each Formula E team in 2020-21

In an eventful Formula E season, punctuated by rain and energy-conservation controversy, the 12 teams contesting the championship have endured many challenges in the opening seven races. Here's how they've got on across the first half of the season.

Formula E
May 26, 2021
How Formula E stood up to F1 comparisons in Monaco Plus

How Formula E stood up to F1 comparisons in Monaco

OPINION: It was no surprise to anybody that the laptimes achieved by Formula E cars on the full Monaco circuit were much slower than Formula 1. But perhaps the more relevant comparison was in the racing spectacle, where FE delivered in spades

Formula E
May 12, 2021